03 Nov 2008: Report
Zimbabwe’s Desperate
Miners Ravage the Land
Hard-pressed by economic straits, illegal panners are tearing up Zimbabwe’s countryside in search of gold and diamonds. They leave behind a trail of destruction: devastated fields and forests, mud-choked rivers, and mercury-tainted water. Andrew Mambondiyani reports from eastern Zimbabwe.
The tarred road from Chimanimani Resort Village in Zimbabwe meandered down to the Haroni River, then broke into a dirt path. Red dust billowed as hundreds of haggard, barefoot illegal diamond miners marched in single file, carrying hoes, picks, and shovels. Women, schoolchildren, young and old men waded across the river to the eastern bank. There they cut trees, overturned rocks, and pushed the debris into the Haroni, choking it with mud. The staccato sound of hammers drowned out the rush of the river.
The Haroni is fast here, driven by gravity where it emerges from the imposing Chimanimani Mountains, which form Zimbabwe’s eastern border with Mozambique. Until recently, the river ran clear. Now it was brown and murky. Until recently, this was coffee, tea, and cattle country, filled with well-tended plantations. Now the landscape had turned to a ghostly panorama of ravaged fields, trees ripped up by their roots and left to rot, gaping holes and tailings, forest cut and burned.
This scene — already familiar in central and western Zimbabwe, where a 19th-century-style gold rush has been taking place since 1990s — has become even more common since 2006, when diamonds were discovered in the country’s eastern areas.
Enlarge image
Illegal miners dig for diamonds
All of Zimbabwe’s 10 provinces bear evidence of the damage. Rivers are filled with silt, harming ecosystems as well as farming, fishing, and drinking water. Miners cut and burn wood indiscriminately to fuel their makeshift camps. Panners use mercury and cyanide to separate gold from the ore, and then flush the toxins into the rivers.
A visibly disturbed deputy environment and tourism minister, Andrew Langa, toured the devastated Chiadzwa diamond fields in the eastern Manicaland province last year. “The cost of reclaiming this land is beyond our means,” he said. “If illegal mining continues at such an alarming rate, Chiadzwa area will be left without a tree or even grass.”
Environment and Tourism Minister Francis Nhema went a step further, telling reporters, “If the illegal mining is not stopped, it could turn the whole country to rubble in the next few years.”
King Solomon’s Mines
The Haroni River is a valuable resource not only for the Chimanimani region of Zimbabwe but also for neighboring Mozambique, as it provides fish and other foods to the people. The river also provides water for hundreds of settlements along the river in both countries. In addition, the Chimanimani region is home to a Zimbabwe national park that is described by the conservation group BirdLife International as “one of the richest ecological complexes in Zimbabwe.”
Illegal miners began flooding into the Chimanimani area in late September 2007, following the discovery of a diamond belt along the Haroni. The miners, who had long hoped for such news — according to myth, the Chimanimani Mountains were the location of King Solomon’s fabulous mines — traveled from as far as Bulawayo, hundreds of miles away in western Zimbabwe.
Barely a day after the diamond belt’s discovery, up to 2,000 illegal miners invaded Charleswood Farm, just across the Haroni River.
Map: Enlarge image
Diamond rush in eastern Zimbabwe
On the western side of the Chimanimani area, meanwhile, a vicious war erupted between the police and illegal miners following the discovery of yet another belt of diamonds. The miners, operating from the top of the sacred Dziike Mountain, rolled stones down the mountain to scare off police officers who had been sent to evict them.
The High Cost of Gold
The scramble for mineral wealth is damaging not only Zimbabwe’s ecology, but also its struggling economic efforts, experts warn.
Even before the diamond rush began, renowned environmentalist James C. Murombedzi wrote in a 2005 study that “unsustainable gold panning activities are directly leading to the decline in water for irrigation, reducing agricultural output, destroying fisheries, and ultimately threatening the country’s water resources.”
The practice “causes massive damage to river systems through channel and riverbank erosion and the discharge of pollutants (mercury and human waste) into the water, leading to sedimentation and siltation,” reported Murombedzi, formerly the Southern Africa regional director of the International Union for Conservation of Nature.
Murombedzi noted that gold panning expanded most rapidly after
Panning was “a significant source of income” for an estimated 600,000 Zimbabweans, according to a 2005 study.the government —responding to pressure from the World Bank and International Monetary Fund — implemented Zimbabwe’s Economic Structural Adjustment Program in the early 1990s. The program of privatization, deregulation, and reduced export subsidies caused dramatic job losses and poverty, leaving many workers scrambling for an informal livelihood.
Panning was “a significant source of income” for an estimated 600,000 Zimbabweans, accounting for about a quarter of the country’s total gold output, Murombedzi reported in his 2005 study. But “the cost of environmental damage caused by gold panning is borne by society at large, while the benefits are appropriated by the panners themselves. As such, there are no real incentives for the panners to engage in sustainable methods of panning.”
The University of Zimbabwe’s Institute of Mining Research had previously reported that illegal panning was prevalent along most of the country’s major rivers.
“Mercury is used especially by alluvial gold panners, and it finds its way into the river systems and the atmosphere since there is no process in use for its recovery and use of cyanide for gold recovery is also prevalent in Zimbabwe,” the institute’s report noted.
One of the most affected river systems is the Save (or Sabi) River, which supplies water to the Middle Sabi and Chisumbanje farming areas in Manicaland province, in the east. Panning for gold and diamonds is rampant along the river’s tributaries, creating silting that has reduced the once mighty river to a trickle.
The Middle Sabi produces more than 25 percent of Zimbabwe’s wheat.
One farmer, Blessing Dube, said in early August that silt had choked his region’s nine giant irrigation pumps for the past two weeks, threatening the entire Middle Sabi farming area — nearly 20,000 acres. “The pumps, the canal, as well as the overnight storage dams, all have been clogged,” he said. “We currently have about 1,830 hectares [more than 4,500 acres] of wheat in various stages of growth and, had it not been for the poor water supply, we were expecting up to 5,400 tons of wheat this season.”
Little Enforcement
After the diamond rush began last year, Environment and Tourism Minister Nhema — who also chairs the United Nations Commission on Sustainable Development — said it had become necessary to put an immediate stop to illegal mining throughout the country.
“We have collectively come to the conclusion that the environmental costs emanating from the panning activities far outweigh the benefits accruing to the panners,” Nhema told journalists.
Nhema said panning had caused chemical contamination of water bodies, indiscriminate cutting down of trees, and destruction of fragile habitats. The mining also eroded any gains from the land reform program as agricultural land was riddled with holes, he said. The minister added that the country’s economic success hinged on economically viable and environmentally sustainable policies.
As pressure mounted from environmentalists last year,
Despite arrests, no panner has been convicted of illegal possession of precious minerals since the penalty was increased.Zimbabwe President Mugabe assented to legislation that imposes a sentence of at least five years on anyone convicted of illegally dealing in or possessing precious stones. Early this fall, police announced that they had arrested 9,656 diamond panners and recovered 1,912 diamonds worth quadrillions of inflated Zimbabwean dollars in the Chiadzwa area since January.
But those figures are misleading. According to court records, no panner has been convicted of illegal possession of precious minerals since the penalty was increased. Convictions have come only for prospecting without a license, a minor offense.
And Manicaland’s new governor, Chris Mushohwe, says illegal mining continues unabated.
“As I speak now,” he told a gathering of church leaders in September, “there are over 20,000 illegal panners hiding in the mountains around Chiadzwa area. I need your support to eradicate this problem.”
POSTED ON 03 Nov 2008 IN Pollution & Health Sustainability Water Africa Asia
ABOUT THE AUTHORAndrew Mambondiyani is an environmental journalist working for a Zimbabwe-based newspaper. His work has won numerous honors, including the Environment Africa Award for reporting on the effects of global warming and climate change on rural communities in Zimbabwe. He received the Zimbabwe Union of Journalists Water Conservation Award in 2005 and the Zimpapers Agricultural Reporter of the Year Award in 2006. Last year, he served as one of the 10 inaugural recipients of the Middlebury College (USA) environmental journalism fellowships.
Stumble UponRELATED ARTICLES
Mountaintop Mining Legacy:
Destroying Appalachia’s Streams
The environmental damage caused by mountaintop removal mining across Appalachia has been well documented. But scientists are now beginning to understand that the mining operations’ most lasting damage may be caused by the massive amounts of debris dumped into valley streams.
A Plea to President Obama:
End Mountaintop Coal Mining
Tighter restrictions on mountaintop removal mining are simply not enough. Instead, a leading climate scientist argues, the Obama administration must prohibit this destructive practice, which is devastating vast stretches of Appalachia.
The Razing of Appalachia:
Mountaintop Removal Revisited
Over the past two decades, mountaintop removal mining in Appalachia has obliterated or severely damaged more than a million acres of forest and buried more than 1,000 miles of streams. Now, the Obama administration is showing signs it plans to crack down on this destructive practice.
In China’s Mining Region,
Villagers Stand Up to Pollution
After decades of living with fouled rivers and filthy air, residents of China’s Manganese Triangle are rising up and refusing to accept the intolerable conditions created by illegal mining activity. Their bold protests have shone light on the dark side of China’s economic boom. From Sichuan province, Chinese journalists Zhou Jigang and Zhu Chuhua report.
Alaska’s Pebble Mine:
Fish Versus Gold
With the support of Gov. Sarah Palin, mining interests have defeated an Alaska ballot measure that could have blocked a huge proposed mining project. Now, plans are moving forward to exploit the massive gold and copper deposit at Bristol Bay, home of one of the world’s greatest salmon runs.
MORE IN Reports
In the Mountains of the Moon,
A Trek to Africa’s Last Glaciers
The shrinking ice cap atop Mount Kilimanjaro is Africa’s most famous glacier. But the continent harbors other pockets of ice, most notably in the Rwenzori Mountains of western Uganda. And as temperatures rise, the Rwenzori’s tropical glaciers — located as high as 16,500 feet — are fast disappearing.
It’s Green Against Green
In Mojave Desert Solar Battle
Few places are as well suited for large-scale solar projects as California’s Mojave Desert. But as mainstream environmental organizations push plans to turn the desert into a center for renewable energy, some green groups — concerned about spoiling this iconic Western landscape — are standing up to oppose them.
The Electric Car Revolution
Will Soon Take to the Streets
For years, the promise and hype surrounding electric cars failed to materialize. But as this year’s Detroit auto show demonstrated, major car companies and well-funded startups — fueled by federal clean-energy funding and rapid improvement in lithium-ion batteries — are now producing electric vehicles that will soon be in showrooms.
Arctic Tundra is Being Lost
As Far North Quickly Warms
The treeless ecosystem of mosses, lichens, and berry plants is giving way to shrub land and boreal forest. As scientists study the transformation, they are discovering that major warming-related events, including fires and the collapse of slopes due to melting permafrost, are leading to the loss of tundra in the Arctic.
Behind Mass Die-Offs,
Pesticides Lurk as Culprit
In the past dozen years, three new diseases have decimated populations of amphibians, honeybees, and — most recently — bats. Increasingly, scientists suspect that low-level exposure to pesticides could be contributing to this rash of epidemics.
Madagascar’s Political Chaos
Threatens Conservation Gains
Since the government's collapse after a coup last March, Madagascar's rainforests have been plundered for their precious wood and unique wildlife. But now there are a few encouraging signs, as officials promise a crackdown on illegal logging and ecotourists begin to return to the island.
Complete Coverage of the
Copenhagen Climate Talks
In Search of New Waters,
Fish Farming Moves Offshore
As wild fish stocks continue to dwindle, aquaculture is becoming an increasingly important source of protein worldwide. Now, a growing number of entrepreneurs are raising fish in large pens in the open ocean, hoping to avoid the many environmental problems of coastal fish farms.
The Copenhagen Diagnosis:
Sobering Update on the Science
On the eve of the Copenhagen conference, a group of scientists has issued an update on the 2007 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Their conclusions? Ice at both poles is melting faster than predicted, the claims of recent global cooling are wrong, and world leaders must act fast if steep temperature rises are to be avoided.
Courting Controversy with
a New View on Exotic Species
A number of biologists are challenging the long-held orthodoxy that alien species are inherently bad. In their contrarian view, many introduced species have proven valuable and useful and have increased the diversity and resiliency of native ecosystems.
RELATED e360 DIGEST ITEMS
09 Feb 2010: Great Lakes Region Looks to
Prevent an Invasion by Asian Carp
08 Feb 2010: Black Soot is Main Cause
Of Himalayan Glacier Melt, Study Says
03 Feb 2010: Parkinson’s Disease Study
Highlights Environmental, Regional Risks
28 Jan 2010: Iceland Tops Environment List,
While U.S., China, and India Lag Far Behind
27 Jan 2010: Exposure to Flame Retardant
Decreases Female Fertility, Study Shows
26 Jan 2010: Interview: Andrew Revkin on the
Rising Heat in the Climate Debate
25 Jan 2010: Gates Fears Climate Funds
Could Siphon Money from Health Programs
22 Jan 2010: Kennedy and Coal Executive
Debate Mountaintop Removal Mining
21 Jan 2010: Pollution from Asia
Boosts Ozone Levels in Western U.S.
20 Jan 2010: ‘Eco-bling’ in the U.K.;
CO2-Spewing Lawns in the U.S.
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies.
DEPARTMENTS
OpinionReports
Analysis
Interviews
e360 Digest
TOPICS
BiodiversityBusiness & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Water
REGIONS
Antarctica and the ArcticAfrica
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America
ABOUT
About e360Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints
CONNECT
BookmarkEmail newsletter
Twitter: YaleE360
e360 on Facebook
Share e360
Subscribe to our feed:
Top Image: aerial view of Iceland. © Google & TerraMetrics.
OF INTEREST
COMMENTS
I have been to Zimbabwe a number of times and this story gives a clear picture of the situation in the country.
but you should also write about the police brutality when they are trying to evict the panners. a number of panners have been shot in the past months.
Instead of the harsh penalties that are not being imposed, make them harsh penalties for dealing in mercury and cyanide -- strict prison terms for both selling and possession should be imposed.
Environmental remediation sentences of a certain time and an education program about the poisoning of the water supply and rivers should be mandatory for all that are caught -- make these people clear out the irrigation channels in lieu of jail time.
A realistic way of making a living must be an alternative if this has any chance of being stopped.
The only way to make a change is to eradicate corruption and help the common man to find another form of income.
Hopefully in time, things will change. Until then, my prayers are with the people.
POST A COMMENT
Comments are moderated and will be reviewed before they are posted to ensure they are on topic, relevant, and not abusive. They may be edited for length and clarity. By filling out this form, you give Yale Environment 360 permission to publish this comment.