18 Nov 2010: Report

Green Tech Sector Advances
Despite Failure of Climate Bill

While the collapse of climate legislation in Congress was a setback for some green businesses, many others are moving ahead with projects to develop renewable energy. One major reason: The clean-tech sector is rapidly growing worldwide, and U.S. companies don’t want to be left behind.

by john carey

With the death of climate legislation in the U.S. Congress, Frank Alix’s job has become a lot tougher. Alix is co-founder and CEO of Powerspan, a New Hampshire-based company that says it has developed a technology for snaring carbon dioxide from power plants. Earlier this year, Alix had been optimistic that Congress would pass a climate bill, offering incentives for carbon capture and storage (CCS) and putting a price tag on emitting carbon. That would have caused a dozen utilities to install Powerspan’s equipment, he figured.

“We as a company and as a group of investors bet that the U.S. might provide leadership,” he says.

That didn’t happen under a Congress controlled by Democrats, and now that the Republican Party has taken control of the House of Representatives, it appears to be a virtual impossibility. There’s widespread agreement in Washington that climate legislation is completely off the table until at least the 2012 election, if then. And Alix’s projected market in the U.S. has evaporated. “Without a price on carbon, these projects will cost hundreds of millions of dollars and no one will do them,” he says.

Yet this isn’t a simple story of a company or an industry defeated by Washington’s inaction. Alix’s Plan A — a booming U.S. market — may be quashed. But he’s got a Plan B and a Plan C: Europe and China. “There are more opportunities there than you would think,” he says. “We’ll figure it out. I just feel this technology is too important to the
The idea that the demise of climate legislation has crippled the U.S. clean-tech sector is a myth.
industry and to the world.”

This mix of disappointment and hope is a common refrain among the business supporters of a climate bill. “The lack of legislation is important, but companies are probably not changing the direction they’re headed in,” explains Linda Fisher, chief sustainability officer at Dupont, which sees growing markets for lightweight plastics for cars, solar panel materials, biofuels, and other Dupont products. “We are not pausing on our growth opportunities.”

The opportunities aren’t as great as they would have been with a bill, of course. For utilities, the lack of a sure price on carbon emissions is slowing plans to build big solar arrays and nuclear power plants, and is accelerating a race to natural gas, as some coal plants are being shut due to coming stricter pollution rules.

“We will be making a huge bet on one fuel [natural gas], which is never a good idea,” says Michael Morris, CEO of giant Ohio-based American Electric Power. And the U.S. economy could suffer as hundreds of companies like Powerspan look elsewhere for investment and markets — and as innovation shifts to other countries.

“This is not just about the price on carbon, this is about who will own the industries of the future,” warns Ron Pernick, co-founder and managing director of Clean Edge, a clean-tech research firm.

But the idea that the demise of climate legislation has crippled the U.S. clean-tech industry is a myth. Venture capital investment in clean energy hit a post-financial crisis high in the second quarter of 2010, reports Bloomberg New Energy Finance. And the percentage of all venture capital flowing into clean-tech in the U.S. hit a new record of 12.5 percent, according to Clean Edge.

“I think people have convinced the media that clean-tech is delayed or tied to the price of carbon,” says Jigar Shah, founder of solar pioneer SunEdison and now CEO of the Carbon War Room. “It’s not. I don’t think the pace is changing.”

Silicon Valley-based ENXSuite, for example, has discovered demand for its energy- and carbon-tracking software has increased since the legislation
‘People are bullish, and the lack of a carbon price looks like just another barrier to leap over,’ says one entrepreneur.
died. The reason: Companies were holding back because of uncertainty over whether or not the bill would pass, says founder and CTO Michael Meehan. A price on carbon was part of his original business plan, Meehan adds, but carbon is now such a politically charged word in the U.S. that the company changed its business model and even its name — from Carbonnetworks to ENXSuite.

And Fremont, Calif.-based GlassPoint Solar has successfully raised money for a demonstration of its solar steam generators for use in enhanced oil recovery. The company knows that the system must be able to compete with natural gas-generated steam without a price on carbon, says John O’Donnell, GlassPoint’s vice president of business development. “Right now, none of our customers is making investment decisions that include carbon risks,” he says.

How has clean-tech been able to survive, or even thrive? One reason is the faith and passion of individual entrepreneurs, says Shah: “What people don’t understand is that to bet your family’s entire net worth to start a company takes extraordinary optimism. Even after Copenhagen and the climate bill, people are just bullish about their ideas — and something like the lack of a carbon price looks like just another barrier to leap over.”

Powerspan
Powerspan
At Powerspan, in New Hampshire, scientists are developing carbon capture technology for power plants.
Another reason is that, even without limits on carbon, other polices and market forces are fueling the development and adoption of lower-emitting technologies. A new report from GTM Research predicts, for instance, that the market for technologies to make the electricity grid “smarter” will grow by more than 70 percent, from $5.6 billion in 2010 to $9.6 billion by 2015. The drivers of the move toward a smart grid are savings from efficiency gains and plentiful dollars from the U.S. government, explains GTM Research smart grid analyst David Leeds: “Thankfully, we have enough federal funding over the next five years.”

Or drop in on ALTe in Auburn Hills, Mich., which has been quietly developing a plug-in gas-electric powertrain for shuttle buses, pickup trucks, and other vehicles. The vehicles are propelled by an electric motor, and an on-board gasoline engine kicks in to recharge the batteries after 40 to 50 miles. While the company has already snared its first order, for 3,000 powertrains, it expects major boosts from a U.S. Energy Department loan and from government procurement rules that mandate purchases of a certain percentage of “green” vehicles. It expects to ramp up to 90,000 units a year, providing a key market for the advanced battery factories also springing up in Michigan.

“We would love climate legislation, but we feel we can sell out our factory for years,” says CEO John Thomas, a veteran of Ford, GM, and Tesla Motors.

Federal and state support also underlies plans by Abengoa Solar to build 280-megawatt solar thermal plants in Arizona and California. Effects of the death of the climate bill? Because the company has already signed a power purchase agreement for the electricity from the plants, there are no effects on these projects “except for feeling a little glum about politics,” says Abengoa senior advisor Fred Morse. And the mere fact that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is requiring carbon emissions to be reported is speeding companies’ efforts to reduce those emissions, says Dupont’s Fisher.

The final reason is that the business world generally believes that limits on carbon, or other policies to promote energy efficiency and renewable power, are inevitable. The EPA is moving ahead with plans to regulate carbon dioxide emissions under the Clean Air Act, for instance.

“We will also see legislation in the new Congress,” predicts John Cohen, vice president of government affairs at Alstom, a French-based
Executives say that the longer the U.S. dithers, the farther it will fall behind.
multinational that makes everything from more efficient coal boilers and steam turbines to carbon capture equipment. “It won’t be economy-wide cap and trade, but it will have energy provisions that will continue the inexorable advance to a clean energy economy,” he says. That’s why Alstom is sticking to its long-term strategy of betting on lower-carbon technologies.

But even as companies remain bullish on clean-tech, there’s a powerful sense of regret among environmentally-oriented companies over the additional progress that could have been made if only Washington had passed a climate bill. With a rising price per ton of CO2, far more big solar plants would have begun to be built, says Abengoa’s Morse. “You’d see a shift out of fossil fuel into renewables,” he says.

Dupont’s Fisher argues that what’s really needed is a transformation of the economy, a complete change in how we produce and use energy. EPA regulations might make a dent in carbon emissions, she says, but they won’t stimulate the innovation needed for such a transformation. A price on fossil fuels would. “I reflect on how fast the market started to change when gasoline hit $5 per gallon,” she says.

And executives say that the longer the U.S. dithers, the farther behind it will fall.

MORE FROM YALE e360

After a Strong Counterattack,
Big Coal Makes a Comeback

After a Strong Counterattack, Big Coal Makes a Comeback
With an aggressive campaign focused on advertising, lobbying, and political contributions, America’s coal industry has succeeded in beating back a challenge from environmentalists and clean-energy advocates. The truth is that Big Coal is more powerful today than ever, Jeff Goodell writes.
READ MORE
“Once again, we are not making the investments today to get ahead of the ultimate game, which is a combination of energy efficiency, renewables and nuclear,” says Ralph Izzo, CEO of New Jersey-based utility PSEG. Absent a price on carbon, PSEG has slowed down its plans for a new nuclear plant, for example, but other nations haven’t. “I think 50 nuclear plants are being built around the world, and only one in the U.S.,” says Izzo. Already, China leads the world in manufacturing solar panels.

So while clean-tech isn’t going to wither away because of inaction in Washington, a huge opportunity to stimulate more innovation and growth is being lost, executives believe. Says Alstom’s Cohen: “Our message is: This is urgent. We need to get on with it now.”

POSTED ON 18 Nov 2010 IN Climate Pollution & Health Science & Technology Asia 

COMMENTS


Just because the Repubs are back in the House doesn't mean you back down from the legislation. You push it, and push it, and you push it. That is one problem with Dems, seemingly our only link to some sort of progressive movement in this nation. The other is, how they sell it.

The right is so good at selling their message. They speak the easy-flow, everyday-joe lingo so well and wrap it all up in gift wrap so people will automatically recognize it as something special and worth tearing into. The left on the other hand (and this in and of itself isn't a bad thing) is far too cerebral and technical. They aren't talking to the people so much as talking at them like a boring professor droning on and on through a never ending lecture about stimulus packages and reform and the need for bipartisanship.

Stop holding hands with people who beat you (because the right is the abusive one, the left the abused). Obama's a nice guy, probably too nice for what he's up against. He should stay nice, but play hard. Any master of the martial arts will tell you, or even any master athlete, it's about being intense without looking intense. You make it look easy. Right now, the Dems have no masters of the craft, and it looks so very painful.

Posted by Mustang on 18 Nov 2010


It's heartening to know that the famed Amercian spirit of invention and innovation is intact even in the midst of political lethargy and myopia. We in India and Asia are waiting with baited breath for the oldest democracy and the largest economy's politicians to provide the leadership their renewable industry is all set to take forward.

Posted by Keshav Chaturvedi on 19 Nov 2010


We invest in sustainable projects across the world - renewable energy, water etc - with a
focus on emerging markets. In this sector, the U.S. is considered one, being so far behind Europe and even some of the emerging economies.

Our investments in the U.S. were only made possible with government tax breaks and grants
under the ARRA. However, that's running out. Unless the government can support the sector
over the long term then the US will indeed fall further behind.

All because U.S. corporate agenda ultimately controls U.S. policy and too many 'little people' are just too ignorant to know it.

Posted by Trip on 25 Nov 2010


Considering the many historic and current dis-economies and intractable problems with atomic fission in our "market economy," the inclusion of nuclear power in an article on clean-tech by this former writer for Business Week is interesting. The author apparently knows little about sustainable energy economics. It has little to do with sustainable atomic reactions. The US has already experienced that failed concept as an economic bomb (along with resultant electric utility restructuring in the 1990s).

Mr. Izzo's disappointment with the climate bill probably had something to due with the failure of the proposed one hundred percent taxpayer backed loan guarantees for atomic fission as well. Nuclear is not by definition renewable, safe or "clean," and is certainly not economical in the current market, like wind or end-use efficiency upgrades.

Posted by James Newberry on 29 Nov 2010


Comments have been closed on this feature.
john careyABOUT THE AUTHOR
John Carey is a freelance writer covering the environment, energy, science, technology and medicine. Until this year, he was senior correspondent at BusinessWeek, where during 21 years he wrote about a range of issues, from sequencing the human genome and global warming to tobacco regulation, election technology, cholesterol-lowering drugs and renewable energy. He is a former editor of The Scientist, and spent six years at Newsweek, where he covered science, technology, and health.
MORE BY THIS AUTHOR

 
 

RELATED ARTICLES


As Arctic Ocean Ice Disappears,
Global Climate Impacts Intensify

The top of the world is turning from white to blue in summer as the ice that has long covered the north polar seas melts away. This monumental change is triggering a cascade of effects that will amplify global warming and could destabilize the global climate system.
READ MORE

What’s Killing Native Birds in
The Mountain Forests of Kauai?

Biologist Eben Paxton is sounding the alarm about the catastrophic collapse of native bird populations on the Hawaiian island of Kauai. His group's research has uncovered the culprit: disease-carrying mosquitoes that have invaded the birds' mountain habitat.
READ MORE

Why We Need a Carbon Tax,
And Why It Won’t Be Enough

Putting a price on carbon is an idea whose time has come, with even Big Oil signaling it may drop its long-standing opposition to a carbon tax. But the question is, has it come too late?
READ MORE

Clinton vs. Trump: A Sharp Divide
Over Energy and the Environment


READ MORE

How Climate Change Could Jam
The World's Ocean Circulation

Scientists are closely monitoring a key current in the North Atlantic to see if rising sea temperatures and increased freshwater from melting ice are altering the “ocean conveyor belt” — a vast oceanic stream that plays a major role in the global climate system.
READ MORE

 

MORE IN Reports


High Stakes on the High Seas:
A Call for International Reserves

by nicola jones
Marine protected areas in national waters have proven successful in helping depleted fish stocks to recover. Now, there is growing momentum for the creation of extensive reserves on the high seas as a way of reversing decades of rampant overfishing.
READ MORE

For China’s Polluted Megacities,
A Focus on Slashing Emissions

by mike ives
The booming industrial center of Shenzhen is a showcase for Chinese efforts to cut CO2 emissions and make the nation's burgeoning cities more livable. But it remains to be seen whether China's runaway industrial development can give way to a low-carbon future.
READ MORE

Rocky Flats: A Wildlife Refuge
Confronts Its Radioactive Past

by fred pearce
The Rocky Flats Plant outside Denver was a key U.S. nuclear facility during the Cold War. Now, following a $7 billion cleanup, the government is preparing to open a wildlife refuge on the site to the public, amid warnings from some scientists that residual plutonium may still pose serious health risks.
READ MORE

Pressure Mounts to Reform Our
Throwaway Clothing Culture

by marc gunther
Americans dispose of about 12.8 million tons of textiles annually — 80 pounds for each man, woman, and child. In the U.S. and around the world, a growing number of environmentalists and clothing industry executives say it’s time to end the wasteful clothing culture and begin making new apparel out of old items on a large scale.
READ MORE

The New Green Grid: Utilities
Deploy ‘Virtual Power Plants’

by maria gallucci
By linking together networks of energy-efficient buildings, solar installations, and batteries, a growing number of companies in the U.S. and Europe are helping utilities reduce energy demand at peak hours and supply targeted areas with renewably generated electricity.
READ MORE

Sticker Shock: The Soaring Costs
Of Germany’s Nuclear Shutdown

by joel stonington
German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s 2011 decision to rapidly phase out the country’s 17 nuclear power reactors has left the government and utilities with a massive challenge: How to clean up and store large amounts of nuclear waste and other radioactive material.
READ MORE

How to Restore an Urban River?
Los Angeles Looks to Find Out

by jim robbins
Officials are moving ahead with a major revitalization of the Los Angeles River – removing miles of concrete along its banks and re-greening areas now covered with pavement. But the project raises an intriguing question: Just how much of an urban river can be returned to nature?
READ MORE

How Growing Sea Plants Can
Help Slow Ocean Acidification

by nicola jones
Researchers are finding that kelp, eelgrass, and other vegetation can effectively absorb CO2 and reduce acidity in the ocean. Growing these plants in local waters, scientists say, could help mitigate the damaging impacts of acidification on marine life.
READ MORE

Vanishing Act: What’s Causing Sharp
Decline in Insects and Why It Matters

by christian schwägerl
Insect populations are declining dramatically in many parts of the world, recent studies show. Researchers say various factors, from monoculture farming to habitat loss, are to blame for the plight of insects, which are essential to agriculture and ecosystems.
READ MORE

For India’s Captive Leopards,
A Life Sentence Behind Bars

by richard conniff
As sightings of leopards in populated areas increase, Indian authorities are trapping the animals and keeping them in captivity — often in small cages without adequate food or veterinary care. The real solution, wildlife advocates say, is to educate the public on how to coexist with the big cats.
READ MORE


e360 digest
Yale
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies
.

SEARCH e360



Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter


CONNECT


ABOUT

About e360
Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


DEPARTMENTS

Opinion
Reports
Analysis
Interviews
Forums
e360 Digest
Podcasts
Video Reports

TOPICS

Biodiversity
Business & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Urbanization
Water

REGIONS

Antarctica and the Arctic
Africa
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

“video
Tribal people and ranchers join together to stop a project that would haul coal across their Montana land.
Watch the video.

e360 MOBILE

Mobile
The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 PHOTO ESSAY

“Alaska
An aerial view of why Europe’s per capita carbon emissions are less than 50 percent of those in the U.S.
View the photos.

e360 VIDEO

“Ugandan
Ugandan scientists monitor the impact of climate change on one of Africa’s most diverse forests and its extraordinary wildlife.
Learn more.

e360 VIDEO

Food waste
An e360 video series looks at the staggering amount of food wasted in the U.S. – a problem with major human and environmental costs.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.

e360 SPECIAL REPORT

“Tainted
A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

OF INTEREST



Yale