29 Oct 2013: The Future of Coal: An e360 Report

A Key Mangrove Forest Faces
Major Threat from a Coal Plant

As Bangladesh makes a controversial turn to coal to produce electricity, the construction of a large coal-fired power plant is threatening the fragile ecosystem of the Sundarbans, the world’s largest mangrove forest.

by jeremy hance

On October 22, Bangladeshi and Indian officials were supposed to hold a ceremony laying the foundation stone for the Rampal power plant, a massive new coal-fired project that will sit on the edge of the Sundarbans, the world's largest mangrove forest. Instead, the governments canceled the ceremony and announced that the project had already been inaugurated in early October by the two countries’ heads of state via a Skype call. While the governments say the change was made because of busy schedules, activists contend the sudden scuttling of the ceremony was more likely due
Yale Environment 360 Future of Coal
to rising pressure against the coal plant, including a five-day march in September that attracted an estimated 20,000 people.

Opponents say that the 1,320 megawatt project could devastate the Sundarbans, Bangladesh's largest forest and the nation's last stronghold of the Bengal tiger. They contend that water diversion to the plant, coupled with air and water pollution and heavy coal barge traffic, could leave the Sundarbans — a UNESCO World Heritage site — an increasingly degraded ecosystem, potentially threatening the livelihoods of some of the

View Gallery
Sundarbans mangrove forest

Mohammed Rakibul Hasan
The Sundarbans lies 80 percent in Bangladesh and 20 percent in India.
half-million people who depend on the great mangrove forest.

"Most of the impacts of [the plant] are negative and irreversible which can't be mitigated in any way," concludes an independent Environmental Impact Assessment of the proposed plant by environmental scientist Abdullah Harun Chowdhury of Khulna University in Bangladesh.

The government says that the plant will produce badly needed power for Bangladesh's 150 million people, about half of whom lack electricity. Officials also contend that Rampal will cause minimal environmental harm. "[The] Sundarbans is our safeguard [against natural disasters], and no power plant will be set up jeopardizing the Sundarbans," declared Monowar Islam, the head of Bangladesh's Power Division.

The construction of the Rampal plant is part of an ambitious government strategy to increase electricity generation to 20,000 megawatts by 2021 — a goal that relies heavily on coal. The current administration of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina is proposing a dozen new coal plants, with more likely to come. Until recently, less than five percent of Bangladesh's
Critics say embracing coal is a reckless strategy for a nation highly vulnerable to sea level rise.
electricity production came from coal. Instead the country produced most of its energy from natural gas and biomass.

Critics of the Rampal plant and the country’s growing embrace of coal argue that it is a reckless strategy for a nation that is consistently rated as one of most vulnerable countries to global warming. Few nations are as low-lying as Bangladesh, and the Sundarbans is one of the country’s most important bulwarks against rising seas and intensifying typhoons and other extreme weather events.

Based on sea level increase projections from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 17 percent of Bangladesh could be engulfed by the sea as waters rise, creating millions of climate refugees. In 2010, Bangladesh's Minister of the Environment and Forests, Hasan Mahmud, said that "in Bangladesh climate change is not a threat; climate change is the reality."

"Bangladesh is already a global hotspot for tropical cyclones and other climatic events and is highly vulnerable to increased intensity of storms," Mahmud said last year. "Two thirds of the country is less than five meters

Click to Enlarge
Rampal plant map

The Rampal power plant will be built near the edge of the Sundarbans.
above sea level and vulnerable to coastal inundation and salinity intrusion, which we are already experiencing."

In 2009, Prime Minister Hasina told the U.N. climate summit in Copenhagen that "the refugees caused by climate change increase day by day." Still, Hasina is a staunch defender of the Rampal coal plant, and her administration is the driving force behind Bangladesh's sudden investment in coal.

First conceived in 2010, the Rampal power plant is a partnership between the Bangladesh Power Development Board and India's state-owned National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC), which will share fifty-fifty ownership of the plant, as well as the electricity it produces. Critics contend that despite being a joint project between India and Bangladesh, Bangladesh will face the environmental and human impacts.

"Coal is big business in India, and no doubt there are powerful interests at play," says Ashish Fernandes, an expert on coal with Greenpeace India. "If Bangladesh is locked into a coal-dependent energy paradigm, companies like NTPC will make significant profits, at the cost of [Bangladesh’s] people and environment."

Like the Rampal coal plant, the Sundarbans mangrove forest — an expanse of wooded tracts that rise out of sediment in the tidal zone — is shared between Bangladesh and India. Around 80 percent of the forest lies within Bangladesh, while the rest is in the Indian state of Bengal. The Sundarbans, a UNESCO World Heritage site, covers 10,000 square kilometers and is vital to locals who have depended on its fisheries and other bounty for centuries.

"[The Sundarbans] plays a significant role in the national economy and it is the largest source of forest products in the country," explains Abu Diyan a local environmentalist and guide.

Roughly the size of Lebanon, the Sundarbans is home to at least 330 plant species, 315 bird species, 210 fish species, 49 mammal species, and 59 species of reptiles. Many of the species are endangered, including the Ganges river dolphin; the masked finfoot, a water bird; and the Bengal
'Situating a coal plant near a unique and already stressed ecosystem is inexcusable,' says an Indian activist.
tiger. Globally, mangrove forests are among the world's most important ecosystems — serving as fish nurseries, havens of biodiversity, and carbon storehouses — but they are increasingly disappearing in the face of coastal development and aquaculture.

The human toll of the coal plant — built just 14 kilometers (8.5 miles) from the edge of the Sundarbans — has already been felt: several hundred families have been forcibly removed to make way for the project and hundreds more are expected to be relocated in the near future. The land they inhabited, mostly shrimp farms and rice paddies, will soon be the scene of the power plant construction.

The government says the Rampal coal plant will suck up 9,150 cubic meters of water from the Passur River every hour and run it through a desalination plant. Since mangroves depend on a brackish mix of fresh and salt water, scientists not only fear that water levels in the Passur river will run low, but also that the blend of fresh-and-salt water could be disrupted, dooming swaths of the Sunderban’s mangroves. Furthermore, water dumped back into Passur River will be up 20 to 25 degrees F warmer than the river water, threatening aquatic species.

"The water of the Sundarbans and surrounding areas will be affected by discharging cooling water, effluents from the ships, and leaching water of the coal from ships," Chowdhury explained in an interview. Experts say

View Gallery
Bengal tiger

Steve Winter/National Geographic/Panthera.org
Fewer than 2,500 Bengal tigers remain in the wild; about 270 live in the Sundarbans.
that the Rampal coal plant will require around 4.72 million tons of coal every year, which the government says will require a ship a day carrying coal through wildlife-rich waters.

Another major concern is the air pollution and toxics generated by the plant, including arsenic, mercury, lead, nickel, and radium. The government says the plant could discharge up to 52,000 tons of sulfur a year, which, depending on the type of coal burned, could lead to acid rain in the Sundarbans and surrounding regions.

"While there is no 'good' location for a coal plant, situating one in or near a unique and already stressed ecosystem like the Sundarbans is inexcusable," says Fernandes.

The government of Bangladesh, which did not respond to numerous requests from Yale Environment 360 for comment, has repeatedly argued that the coal plant will have little or no environmental impact. "[The Rampal coal plant] would be built using the latest ultra super critical technology, so it would not affect the environment of Sundarban," Tawfiq-e-Elahi Chowdhury, an adviser to the Prime Minister, said in September.

He added that "the matter has to be understood with a scientific outlook, not emotion. [Opponents’] criticism is not based on information and technological knowledge. Our decision is based on real terms, and not emotions."

According to a recent press note from the government, the plant will only burn "high-quality imported coal," and "emissions of carbon, sulfur, fly ash and several other sorts of air pollution will be kept at a minimum level to avoid having any adverse impact on the environment."

However, conservationists and some scientists have harshly criticized the government's EIA for downplaying threats and spreading misinformation. For one thing, the government EIA treats the Sundarbans as a "residential and rural area" and not an "ecologically critical area." That designation
Conservationists argue that coal is not the best answer to Bangladesh’s shortage of electricity.
allows the government to impose lower thresholds for pollutants, including sulfur and nitrogen.

"It defies logic to treat the Sundarbans, the largest mangrove forest in the world . . . as a residential area," economist Anu Muhammad with Jahangirnagar University told The Independent newspaper of Bangladesh.

Furthermore, critics say the government had already tacitly approved the coal plant before the EIA was even written or submitted to the Environment Ministry for approval. In 2010 the government had already obtained 1,834 hectares (4,532 acres) of land for the project, an acquisition that pushed locals off their ancestral land.

Mowdud Rahman, an engineer with the Southeast Asia Renewable Energy People’s Assembly, says that the EIA process was "used as an instrument to rationalize a predetermined project."

He and others say that coal is not the best answer to Bangladesh’s shortage of electricity. Increasing efficiency at existing gas plants could add 2,500 megawatts in one year — nearly double the electricity production of the Rampal coal plant, Rahman says. In addition, he says, Bangladesh should

look to biogas, mini-hydroelectric, wind, and solar for its energy needs. Currently, the Bangladesh government has set a goal of producing 5 percent of its electricity with renewable energy by 2015 and 10 percent by 2020.

"Unfortunately this only seems to be a juicy target with no substantial attempt to make it happen," says Rahman.

In September, concerned Bangladeshis took their opposition to the streets. At the end of the 400-kilometer march, activist leaders released the "Long March Declaration," which demanded that the government cancel the project by October 11. Nevertheless, the project is moving ahead.

"We have frequently said there are alternatives for producing electricity, but there are no alternatives to the Sundarbans," the declaration read.



POSTED ON 29 Oct 2013 IN Biodiversity Business & Innovation Climate Energy Energy Forests Policy & Politics Water Asia Europe North America 

COMMENTS


First of all I love what e360 is doing to help educate the public on important environmental issues around the world as well as here at home. I have recommended e360 to all of my friends and family.

One thing that truly saddens me, though, is reading these articles and feeling helpless (unless they are those great positive articles like the U.S. possibly/finally jumping on board with wind energy!). What is it that I can do? I try to be as environmentally conscious as possible. I raise my own chickens, grow a veggie garden, do not litter, and attempt to recycle (upcycle) everything I possibly can. But what can I do to have an impact on these bigger issues? I know that all my little things do add up to big things, eventually, but my little things are not going to help the endangered species of animal and plant life outside of the U.S. Suggestions?
Posted by Jen on 30 Oct 2013


Unbelievable. They want to develop coal energy knowing its country is one the most susceptible in terms of sea level rise and having the alternative. What do they expect? They hope that somehow laws of physics won't work this time?
Posted by tkloszewski on 30 Oct 2013


Jeremy, one thing should be added: That 12,000 tons of coal will transported through the Sundarbans Channel, small rivers by small vessels. So it will destroy the ecosystem largely.

We only have Sundabans as our natural safeguard, which has saved us from various devastating natural disasters at the past. Though we are raising our voices to create awareness and funds to fight the effects of global warming, we have forgotten about our savior and are destroying it heartlessly.

What a joke, the dual character of our government!

Posted by Sushanta sinha on 31 Oct 2013


Why coal-based thermal? Why nuclear? Why not solar-based power generation!

When will we start thinking for the future? The alternative is solar power.

http://rampalproject.blogspot.in/2013/10/a-comparative-study-between-coal-based.html
Posted by Shyam K Mondal on 01 Nov 2013


For those who are concerned and keen to participate in this forest-saving movement, you can start a petition addressing UNESCO (as Sundarbans is a UNESCO-declared world heritage site) and RAMSAR authorities (this forest is a RAMSAR site too) to make them aware of this devastating coal-based power plant.
Posted by Mowdud Rahman on 03 Nov 2013


POST A COMMENT

Comments are moderated and will be reviewed before they are posted to ensure they are on topic, relevant, and not abusive. They may be edited for length and clarity. By filling out this form, you give Yale Environment 360 permission to publish this comment.

Name 
Email address 
Comment 
 
Please type the text shown in the graphic.


jeremy hanceABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jeremy Hance is a senior writer for Mongabay.com, one of the leading sites on the Web covering tropical forests and biodiversity. He is the author of the book Life is Good: Conservation in an Age of Mass Extinction. In earlier articles for Yale e360, Hance reported on the growing use of camera traps to study rare or reclusive species in remote habitats and how industrial fisheries are reducing the harm they inflict on seabirds.
MORE BY THIS AUTHOR

 
 

RELATED ARTICLES


How Drones Are Emerging
As Valuable Conservation Tool

Lian Pin Koh believes drones can be a key part of conservation efforts, particularly in remote regions. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, he talks about how his project, ConservationDrones, is promoting the use of drones for everything from counting orangutans to stopping poaching.
READ MORE

A New Frontier for Fracking:
Drilling Near the Arctic Circle

Hydraulic fracturing is about to move into the Canadian Arctic, with companies exploring the region's rich shale oil deposits. But many indigenous people and conservationists have serious concerns about the impact of fracking in more fragile northern environments.
READ MORE

As Small Hydropower Expands,
So Does Caution on Its Impacts

Small hydropower projects have the potential to bring electricity to millions of people now living off the grid. But experts warn that planners must carefully consider the cumulative effects of constructing too many small dams in a single watershed.
READ MORE

Why Restoring Wetlands
Is More Critical Than Ever

Along the Delaware River estuary, efforts are underway to restore wetlands lost due to centuries of human activity. With sea levels rising, coastal communities there and and elsewhere in the U.S. and Europe are realizing the value of wetlands as important buffers against flooding and tidal surges.
READ MORE

Primate Rights vs Research:
Battle in Colombian Rainforest

A Colombian conservationist has been locked in a contentious legal fight against a leading researcher who uses wild monkeys in his search for a malaria vaccine. A recent court decision that banned the practice is seen as a victory in efforts to restrict the use of monkeys in medical research.
READ MORE

 

MORE IN The Future of Coal: An e360 Report


In South Africa, Renewables Vie
With the Political Power of Coal

by adam welz
Although coal has dominated the South African electricity sector for decades, the country’s abundant solar and wind resources offer a promising renewable energy alternative. But entrenched political interests connected to the ruling party are fighting to expand coal’s role in the national economy.
READ MORE

In Australia, an Uphill Battle
To Rein in the Power of Coal

by samiha shafy
Australia is the world’s second-largest exporter of coal, thanks to huge markets in China, Japan, and other Asian countries. Environmentalists have been struggling to scale back the nation’s coal boom, but the recent election of a conservative prime minister may keep coal on top.
READ MORE

Facing Tough Market at Home,
U.S. Coal Giant Pushes Overseas

by lisa palmer
With prospects in the U.S. increasingly uncertain, Peabody Energy, the world’s largest private coal company, is expanding its operations abroad. But that strategy could carry significant risks, as coal-consuming powerhouses like China are working to reduce their dependence on the fossil fuel.
READ MORE

Will Global Coal Boom Go Bust
As Climate Concerns Increase?

by fen montaigne
The surge in global coal consumption, driven largely by China and India, has climate scientists deeply worried. But environmentalists and a growing number of financial experts say that alarm over global warming may halt the seemingly inevitable rise of the coal industry.
READ MORE


e360 digest
Yale
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies
.

SEARCH e360



Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter

CONNECT

Twitter: YaleE360
e360 on Facebook
Donate to e360
View mobile site
Bookmark
Share e360
Subscribe to our newsletter
Subscribe to our feed:
rss


ABOUT

About e360
Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


DEPARTMENTS

Opinion
Reports
Analysis
Interviews
Forums
e360 Digest
Podcasts
Video Reports

TOPICS

Biodiversity
Business & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Urbanization
Water

REGIONS

Antarctica and the Arctic
Africa
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America

e360 PHOTO GALLERY

“Peter
Photographer Peter Essick documents the swift changes wrought by global warming in Antarctica, Greenland, and other far-flung places.
View the gallery.

e360 MOBILE

Mobile
The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 VIDEO

Warriors of Qiugang
The Warriors of Qiugang, a Yale Environment 360 video that chronicles the story of a Chinese village’s fight against a polluting chemical plant, was nominated for a 2011 Academy Award for Best Documentary (Short Subject). Watch the video.


header image
Top Image: aerial view of Iceland. © Google & TerraMetrics.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado River Video
In a Yale Environment 360 video, photographer Pete McBride documents how increasing water demands have transformed the Colorado River, the lifeblood of the arid Southwest. Watch the video.

OF INTEREST



Yale