27 Aug 2012:

In Bolivia, A Battle Over
A Highway and a Way of Life

Growing conflicts over development in South America have come to a head in Bolivia, where indigenous groups are resisting a highway project that would slice through a national park. How Bolivia resolves this showdown could point the way for other regions seeking to balance economic growth and the environment.

by jean friedman-rudovsky

Carmelo Aguilera steadies the dugout canoe as his 11-year-old son, Juan Gabriel, stands precariously and aims his bow and arrow toward the Secure River below. “Fish flesh makes better bait,” says the boy, explaining why the dawn expedition begins with a hunter’s weapon rather than a hook and line.

Deep inside Bolivia’s Isiboro Sécure National Park and Indigenous Territory, known as TIPNIS, the Aguileras live more than 30 hours by boat from the nearest city, surviving mainly on fish and a few homegrown crops. “The river is our lifeblood,” says Aguilera, 62.

Bolivia has been embroiled in conflict for the past year over the planned construction of a 182-mile highway, 32 miles of which would cut through TIPNIS, a vital ecosystem — located at the geographic heart of South

Video: Can Bolivia’s Indigenous Culture Survive a Big Highway?

In an e360 video report, Noah Friedman-Rudovsky explores how a highway proposed through the heart of the Bolivian national park known as TIPNIS will affect local indigenous communities.
Watch the video
America — that links the Andes and the Amazon basins. The road would be an important addition to Bolivia’s woefully undeveloped highway system. Yet environmental studies predict that the project will cause widespread damage, contaminating the park’s three main rivers, opening large areas of forest to illegal logging and settlement, and altering habitats that are home to 11 endangered species and rare primates. All that would threaten the traditional way of life of the reserve’s three dwindling indigenous cultures — the Tsimanes, Yuracarés and Mojeño-Trinitarios.

“Our future,” says Aguilera, a Yuracaré elder, “is uncertain.”

The controversy has brought Bolivia to a crossroads, one that is emblematic of the complex choices over development now confronting much of South America. Bolivia’s highway project is part of a Brazilian-led effort commonly known as IIRSA, or the Initiative for the Regional Integration of South America — a vast network of 531 mega-projects including hydroelectric dams, highways, bridges, and electrical power systems that seeks to propel the continent into the 21st century. Although these projects are filling a major infrastructure void, most are being constructed within the fragile ecosystems of the Amazon basin, which environmentalists warn could do irreparable damage to the world’s largest tropical forest.

If built, the TIPNIS road would likely be a major transport route for moving Brazilian soybeans to Pacific ports for shipment to China. Brazil’s oil giant, Petrobras, also holds exploration rights inside TIPNIS near the
The plan has proven to be a political minefield for Bolivian President Evo Morales.
planned highway. This has prompted critics to charge that the TIPNIS road and other IIRSA projects are designed primarily to benefit Brazilian industry rather than to provide economic and social advancement for the people of Bolivia and the Amazon basin. To deflect growing criticism over IIRSA, Brazil has vowed to give greater weight to the environmental and social aspects of these megaprojects and has recently renamed the effort the South American Council on Infrastructure and Planning, or COSIPLAN.

The controversy over the TIPNIS road, which has involved marches by indigenous groups to the capital and clashes with police, has proven to be a political minefield for President Evo Morales, Bolivia’s first indigenous head of state. Morales has gained an international reputation as a modern day Captain Planet: As a staunch defender of pachamama, or Mother Earth, he has bounded from United Nations meetings to global summits lambasting the developed world for wreaking environmental havoc with its insatiable appetite for oil and consumer goods. He has also consistently called for consultation with indigenous people affected by development projects.

Unfortunately, Morales did not heed his own advice, expressing support for the TIPNIS road without consulting the park’s indigenous people. The plan, which has been on the country’s drawing boards for more than a decade, had always been popular among most Bolivians. But after being slighted by Morales, 1,000 people, including several hundred from the park, marched 350 miles in August 2011 to the capital of La Paz in protest. Popular sentiment started to turn against the highway, in part because the police clashed with the group halfway through their journey. Fearing for his presidency, the Bolivian leader canceled the project soon after the march reached La Paz.

By early this year, however, the plan was back on the table, with Bolivian officials arguing that the TIPNIS road is vital for South America’s poorest nation. “The majority of the population needs integration and needs transport for their goods,” says Vice-Minister of the Environment Beatriz
A paved road through TIPNIS could lead to a virtual free-for-all for loggers.
Zapata. Indeed, in a country almost three times the size of Montana, only one east-west paved highway exists, and it’s impossible to drive from north to south in Bolivia without encountering long stretches of dirt road. By slicing straight through TIPNIS, the proposed highway would cut current travel time around the park from 15 hours to about one hour, easing transport and connecting the country’s economic center of Santa Cruz with isolated northwest Bolivia.

The Morales government is now in the midst of a three-month consultation period with the indigenous people of TIPNIS, determining whether the road can be built in a way that would mitigate its environmental and cultural impacts. “We are moving from a purely conservationist vision onto one that integrates it with development,” says Zapata.

Residents of the 4,000-square-mile park are highly polarized, with the indigenous people of the north — whose ancestors have been living in this area since before the colonial conquest — generally against the road. They are families like the Aguileras, who live off the river and have minimal contact with life outside the park. Given the possible impact of the road on their forests, wild game, and rivers, Delmi Morales Nosa, a Yuracaré mother of two, says, “Our entire way of life will be changed.”

Bolivia Tipnis highway

Noah Friedman-Rudovsky
Last year, hundreds of TIPNIS residents marched 350 miles to the capital of La Paz to protest the highway plan.
Some TIPNIS residents do express frustration with their isolation and lack of transport options. To help his frequently ill wife, Carmelo Aguilera must row several hours to the nearest health clinic, which is third-rate and poorly stocked. TIPNIS’ largest town, Gondonovia — with 84 families — has the only high school in the park’s northern half, so students are forced to either drop out or board at the school. Residents dread the dry season when they are rendered virtually immobile because portions of the rivers get too low to navigate. “It’s not that we’re against development,” said Matilda Vargas, another TIPNIS resident, during last year’s march to La Paz, “but development has to bring us tangible benefits.”

In fact, says Silvia Molina, of the Bolivian Forum on the Environment, aside from cutting transport time for some goods, “there have been no studies quantifying the economic benefit of the highway for Bolivia. So we have no way of gauging whether the benefits are worth the environmental and social costs.” Molina said that in addition to Brazilian business interests, supporters of the road include large landowners poised to expand ranching and agriculture into areas the highway would make accessible. “This highway is for the interests of big business,” Molina concludes. “We need development that is sustainable and prioritizes the needs of the people.”

Many scientists and conservationists say the planned road will irrevocably alter TIPNIS. Already, coca growers in the south of the park — who staunchly support the road — are making incursions into TIPNIS.

“The construction of the highway would be a mortal blow to the entire ecosystem,” says biologist Percy Bautista of Bolivia’s largest public university, the Higher University of San Andres, in La Paz. Most of the impact, he says, will come as the road paves the way for unrestrained human activity inside the park’s remote and most densely forested region.

A never-released study written by an offshoot of the Bolivian government’s Forestry Service predicts that for every mile of paved roadway, up to six square miles will likely be deforested for a new agricultural frontier based mainly on coca. Just south of the park is the Chapare, Bolivia’s second-
The construction of the highway would be a mortal blow to the entire ecosystem,’ says one scientist.
largest coca-growing region and in recent years these farmers have all but transformed the park’s southern half from communities that relied on subsistence agriculture to a dependence on coca as a cash crop. Coca growing is legal in Bolivia, although it is illegal inside the park. The government repeatedly promises to crack down on coca farmers in TIPNIS, but has lacked the capability — or the will — to stop the incursion. (Chapare farmers are President Morales’ base, and he still holds his long-time post as president of their coca-growers union).

Coca growers typically slash and burn forests to prepare them for a crop and then reap numerous annual harvests: Bautista calls intensive coca cultivation “the agricultural equivalent of mining,” leading to severe erosion of soils into creeks and rivers. That, plus the pollution and waste from farms, human settlements, and vehicles, poses a major risk to thriving fish populations in the Isiboro, Secure, and Ichoa rivers, says Bautista.

Bolivia Tipnis highway

Noah Friedman-Rudovsky
Although now temporarily suspended, construction has already begun on part of the planned highway.
Increased illegal logging, the unpublished government report concludes, will likely be another inevitable consequence of the highway. While sustainable forest management is legal in the park, Bautista notes that a paved road through TIPNIS could lead to a virtual free-for-all for loggers. The Bolivian government has rarely been able to safeguard nationally protected areas from such onslaughts, and with only 19 rangers and no police force inside the entire TIPNIS territory, it’s unlikely this will change.

Finally, all this will take its toll on the park’s animals and wildlife habitat, the report concludes. Several of TIPNIS’ species are valuable black market commodities, including caimans, jaguars, and rare primates, and a highway will inevitably spur increased hunting and wildlife trafficking. “The destruction will grow, little by little, from the highway outwards,” says Bautista.

Critics of the road are skeptical of the government’s newfound openness to alternatives, given that the Morales administration has been loathe to consider any proposal other than the original plan that cuts through the heart of the park. Ironically it might never have come to this standoff had Morales initially consulted with TIPNIS residents and won them over. “He was their hero,” says a source who has worked inside TIPNIS for years, “and he took that popularity for granted, assuming they’d never seriously oppose his plans.”

But now their anger is visceral. Following their most recent march to La Paz this past winter, the highway protesters were ignored by the government for two weeks as they slept on La Paz’s frigid streets. They returned to their territory vowing to defend it at all costs: “With bows and arrows, what else?” said Mariano Nogales Rocha.

Watch a video report

POSTED ON 27 Aug 2012 IN Business & Innovation Energy North America 


The point that Vice-Minister Zapata makes about "moving from a purely conservationist vision onto one that integrates it with development" is valid. But the question is where is the argument supporting her stance? Where are the successfully developed green engineering models that can achieve this dual goal and which she is using to buttress her point?

I would suggest as a second level to this article and the discussion that has been provoked that the authors look into best practices of "Smart Green Infrastructure (SGI)" designs options that integrate biodiversity/ecosystem protection and economic development within the regional integration context. Presenting replicable examples of green linear infrastructure - highways, power transmission, bridges, tunnels etc could potentially redirect the discussion from what can or cannot be done to how do Bolivian government in consensus with indigenous communities in the National Park, identify and select engineering design options that could avoid any irreparable impacts on the ecosystem services provision capacity of the park.

Jean and Noah, thank you very much for publishing your findings but I think a follow-up article on SGI options will help tie the loose ends. I would also like to reiterate that one cannot put the horse before the cart when it comes to infrastructure development and therefore informing and involving local communities right at the prescreening stage of the project concept has and still remain a critical planning step.

Posted by Dora Cudjoe on 31 Aug 2012

The Brazilian government is a government of the rich for the rich. They have as a whole (with a few exceptions) allowed the destruction of the Amazon Forest for the benefit a few. Any project initiated or support by them should be suspect. I am amazed that Evo Morales (a man I considered well read and environmentally conscience) is supporting the road. It would be hoped that he listens to the natives and finds an alternative solution for the road.

Posted by Carmen Bonilla-Jones on 31 Aug 2012

Smart Green Infrastructure sounds like yet another highly attractive concept. In theory, all kinds of options can be achieved IF they are supported on-the-ground by the values and goals that roads and in-migrations bring and include powerful local governance to enforce the green objectives of the plan. Since these prerequisites are largely absent in infrastructure development plans, the results are predictable -- local people will resist the plan and governments will avoid consulting with them.

In one of the best I've best essays I've seen on the topic, Joshua J. Yates penetrates to the profound ambiguity embedded in the sustainable-development meme, and why it is both all-important and thus far meaningless.

Well worth reading and pondering at: http://www.iasc-culture.org/THR/THR_article_2012_Summer_Yates.php

Posted by Lou Gold on 01 Sep 2012

Comments have been closed on this feature.
jean friedman-rudovskyABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jean Friedman-Rudovsky is a freelance journalist based in La Paz, Bolivia, where she has been reporting for print, radio and television since 2006. She is the Time magazine reporter in Bolivia and a frequent contributor to Science. Her work has appeared in The New York Times, The Economist, Foreign Policy, Christian Science Monitor, Village Voice Media, Sierra, Democracy Now and other publications. Research support for this article was provided by the Investigative Fund of the Nation Institute



How Nations Are Chipping
Away at Their Protected Lands

Winning protected status for key natural areas and habitat has long been seen as the gold standard of conservation. But these gains are increasingly being compromised as governments redraw park boundaries to accommodate mining, logging, and other development.

Rallying Hip Hop Culture For
A More Inclusive Climate Fight

In an interview with Yale Environment 360, the Rev. Lennox Yearwood — a social and environmental activist and the head of the Hip Hop Caucus — explains why it’s vital that the climate and environmental movements become far more diverse.

A New Face at the Helm of
The Oldest U.S. Green Group

The Sierra Club has chosen Aaron Mair as its president, the first African-American to lead the largest U.S. environmental organization. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he talks about the lack of diversity in the environmental movement and what can be done to change that.

Nicaragua Canal: A Giant Project
With Huge Environmental Costs

Work has already begun on a $50 billion inter-ocean canal in Nicaragua that would cut through nature reserves and bring massive dredging and major ship traffic to Central America’s largest lake. Scientists and conservationists are warning that the project is an environmental disaster in the making.

For Vulnerable Barrier Islands,
A Rush to Rebuild on U.S. Coast

Despite warnings from scientists, new construction continues on U.S. barrier islands that have been devastated by storms. The flood protection projects that accompany this development can have harmful consequences for coastal ecosystems being buffeted by climate change.


MORE IN Reports

As Drought Grips South Africa,
A Conflict Over Water and Coal

by keith schneider
Facing one of the worst droughts in memory, South Africa’s leaders have doubled down on their support of the water-intensive coal industry. But clean energy advocates say the smartest move would be to back the country’s burgeoning wind and solar power sectors.

Saving Amphibians: The Quest
To Protect Threatened Species

by jim robbins
The decline of the world’s amphibians continues, with causes ranging from fungal diseases to warmer and drier climates. Now, researchers are looking at ways to intervene with triage measures that could help save the most vulnerable populations.

How Rising CO2 Levels May
Contribute to Die-Off of Bees

by lisa palmer
As they investigate the factors behind the decline of bee populations, scientists are now eyeing a new culprit — soaring levels of carbon dioxide, which alter plant physiology and significantly reduce protein in important sources of pollen.

Can Uber-Style Buses Help
Relieve India's Air Pollution?

by jason overdorf
India’s megacities have some the deadliest air and worst traffic congestion in the world. But Indian startups are now launching initiatives that link smart-phone apps and private shuttle buses and could help keep cars and other motorized vehicles off the roads.

Trouble in Paradise: A Blight
Threatens Key Hawaiian Tree

by richard schiffman
The ʻohiʻa is Hawaii’s iconic tree, a keystone species that maintains healthy watersheds and provides habitat for numerous endangered birds. But a virulent fungal disease, possibly related to a warmer, drier climate, is now felling the island’s cherished 'ohi'a forests.

Climate Change Adds Urgency
To Push to Save World’s Seeds

by virginia gewin
In the face of rising temperatures and worsening drought, the world’s repositories of agricultural seeds may hold the key to growing food under increasingly harsh conditions. But keeping these gene banks safe and viable is a complicated and expensive challenge.

As World Warms, How Do We
Decide When a Plant is Native?

by janet marinelli
The fate of a tree planted at poet Emily Dickinson's home raises questions about whether gardeners can — or should — play a role in helping plant species migrate in the face of rising temperatures and swiftly changing botanical zones.

With New Tools, A Focus
On Urban Methane Leaks

by judith lewis mernit
Until recently, little was known about the extent of methane leaking from urban gas distribution pipes and its impact on global warming. But recent advances in detecting this potent greenhouse gas are pushing U.S. states to begin addressing this long-neglected problem.

Is Climate Change Putting
World's Microbiomes at Risk?

by jim robbins
Researchers are only beginning to understand the complexities of the microbes in the earth’s soil and the role they play in fostering healthy ecosystems. Now, climate change is threatening to disrupt these microbes and the key functions they provide.

As Electric Cars Stall, A Move
To Greener Trucks and Buses

by cheryl katz
Low gasoline prices and continuing performance issues have slowed the growth of electric car sales. But that has not stymied progress in electrifying larger vehicles, including garbage trucks, city buses, and medium-sized trucks used by freight giants like FedEx.

e360 digest
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies


Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter



About e360
Submission Guidelines

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


e360 Digest
Video Reports


Business & Innovation
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology


Antarctica and the Arctic
Central & South America
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

Tribal people and ranchers join together to stop a project that would haul coal across their Montana land.
Watch the video.


The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.


An aerial view of why Europe’s per capita carbon emissions are less than 50 percent of those in the U.S.
View the photos.

e360 VIDEO

The 2015 Yale e360 Video Contest winner documents a Northeastern town's bitter battle over a wind farm.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Food waste
An e360 video series looks at the staggering amount of food wasted in the U.S. – a problem with major human and environmental costs.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.


A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.