Menu
27 Nov 2012

The Dirty War Against Africa’s Remaining Rhinos

The killing of rhinoceroses has escalated dramatically, especially in South Africa, which is home to 75 percent of the world’s rhino population. The slaughter is being orchestrated by brazen, highly organized gangs that smuggle the rhinos' horns to black markets in China and Southeast Asia.
By adam welz

On November 5, Chumlong Lemtongthai, a 43-year-old Thai national, put his tightly scrawled signature to a guilty plea that was submitted to a South African court. As Accused Number 1 in case 143/2011, he admitted to arranging the illegal hunting of 26 rhinoceroses and the export of their horns to a company in Laos. The plea ends on an unassuming note: “I humbly apologize to the court and the people of South Africa for my role in this matter. I appreciate that the emotions of all animal lovers in South Africa are running very high and that I was part of the problem.”

“The problem” required no further explanation for the judge, nor would it for most of his countrymen. Asian buyers, many in China and Vietnam, now pay upward of $50,000 per kilogram for rhino horn, to which they ascribe various powerful healing properties. An international ban on the trade of rhino horn has created skyrocketing demand on the black market, leading criminal poaching and smuggling gangs to descend on South Africa — home to most of the world’s rhino — with horrific results.

View gallery
Rhinoceros South Africa

Cameron Spencer/Getty Images
A black rhinoceros at Edeni Game Reserve in South Africa.
In 2007 only 13 rhino were poached in the country, about the average annual number since 1990. In 2008, the number rose sharply to 83, in 2009, to 123, and so on. This year — which isn’t over yet — 585 rhino have been illegally killed in South Africa.

Local news bulletins regularly report macabre discoveries of rhino carcasses with bloody holes carved into their snouts, deadly firefights between game rangers and heavily armed poachers deep in the bush, or the arrest of Asian “tourists” caught leaving the region with suitcases full of horn. Angry citizens have formed pressure groups to lobby government, raise money for rhino protection, and demonstrate noisily outside courthouses where suspected rhino criminals are on trial. That’s what they were doing when an impassive, shaven-headed Lemtongthai stood in the dock to receive the strictest sentence ever imposed in South Africa for wildlife crime: Framing the rhino as a symbol of Africa and poaching as an affront to African pride, Judge Prince Manyathi sentenced him to 40 years.

Conservationists were elated, some calling it the sort of deterrent that was required to put an end to the carnage. But their joy didn’t last long; a week later, 11 rhino were found on a single day at two private ranches northwest of Johannesburg. Investigators arrested suspects in a poor neighborhood nearby — among them a game ranger — as a newly orphaned baby rhino, found wandering alone in the bush, was taken to an animal sanctuary.

Rhinos of the World

There are five species of rhinoceros, all of which are found in either Africa or Asia. Click here to see a description of the different rhino species and sub-species, where they live in the wild, the state of their populations, and the threats they face.
Although poaching has recently increased in other countries where rhinos live, South Africa is the epicenter of the epidemic because it is home to 75 percent of the world’s rhino, including 93 percent of by far the most numerous type, the southern white rhino. There are over 18,000 southern whites and about 2,000 black rhino within its borders. (Poachers favor white rhino because they’re typically less aggressive than black and often carry bigger horns.)

In the past, rhino were typically killed by impoverished local people using cheap firearms provided by black market middlemen. Although this kind of poaching is still common, increased security around rhino and the increased profits flowing from the horn trade have resulted in the emergence of more sophisticated criminal networks.

Smuggling gangs now recruit “triggermen” with military backgrounds equipped with silenced rifles and night vision equipment. Small helicopters, flying below air traffic control radar, are used to get poachers into and horn out of protected areas quickly. Wildlife veterinarians are bribed to provide
Gangs recruit poachers with military backgrounds and equip them with silenced rifles and night vision equipment.
locations of unprotected rhino or stocks of M99, a powerful drug used to sedate the animals for research.

Some well-resourced triggermen bring rhino down with darts containing M99 and then cut the horns from their faces with machetes or chainsaws while they are sedated but still alive. Even though a rhino that is injured like this will usually bleed to death within a day, the fact that it does not die immediately gives poachers more getaway time — game rangers have learned to look for circling vultures to alert them to freshly-killed animals, and a live rhino, even if mortally wounded, will not attract a kettle of scavenging birds.

Many others, including Chumlong Lemtongthai, have abused the system governing legal rhino trophy hunts to get past the international ban on horn trading currently in force under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). Since 1968, South Africa has sold a small quota of expensive hunting permits, covering less than 1 percent of the white rhino population per year, to foreign trophy hunters. The millions of dollars raised from these hunts has benefited game ranchers and expanded land under conservation. The permits are granted on condition that the hunter in whose name they are granted fires the first shot at the animal, and that horns are exported to the hunter’s home address fully mounted by a taxidermist, never to be sold.

Lemtongthai applied for multiple hunting permits in the names of Thai sex workers, who he paid to travel to a game ranch and pose, trophy hunter-style, with rhinos that had been shot by his South African accomplices. The horns then traveled from South Africa to southeast Asia as legal trophies, with official papers to “prove” it.

View gallery
White Rhinoceros South Africa

Rodger Bosch/AFP/Getty Images
A badly injured white rhinoceros that had been attacked by poachers.
South Africa’s rhino populations are still rising despite the poachers’ onslaught. Rhino breed well under natural conditions, and about 1,400 southern whites were likely born last year. But this is little comfort to conservationists: A wave of poaching between 1970 and the late 1980s cut the African continent’s black rhino population by an estimated 94 percent, from more than 70,000 down to only 3,800. Two rhino subspecies have recently been declared extinct due to poaching, the western subspecies of black rhino and the Vietnamese subspecies of Javan rhino. The northern white rhino may be the next to vanish forever as only seven animals of this type are known to remain, all in captivity; the last wild population, in the Democratic Republic of Congo, was wiped out by 2008. Assuming that current rates of illegal killing are maintained, South Africa’s rhino population will begin to decline in 2016, according to a government researcher.

In South Africa, the first response to the escalation in poaching has been increased direct protection for the animals themselves. Game rangers have had their arms upgraded to take on the poaching gangs, and the military, operating under an unofficial shoot-to-kill policy, has been brought into Kruger National Park, where hundreds of rhino have been lost. Private game ranchers, who control a quarter of South Africa’s rhino, have installed advanced intruder detection equipment and employed new security teams, many of which are run by ex-Iraq and Afghan war “security contractors”; some owners are now trying out drones to patrol their land.

Many rhino owners have resorted to dehorning – shortening their animals’ horns — to make them less attractive targets. A rhino horn is made up
Many rhino owners have resorted to shortening their animals’ horns to make them less attractive targets.
largely of keratin, the protein in human hair and fingernails, and is similar to a horse’s hoof. If it’s cut off carefully, without harming the sensitive base, it will re-grow in a few years. Some biologists don’t like this approach — a rhino’s horn is, after all, its means of defense — and poachers will sometimes kill a rhino for the short stump of horn that remains. But many owners claim it’s been effective in deterring the triggermen. Others douse horns in unsightly, brightly-colored pesticide.

Increased poaching means substantially increased cost and risk to rhino owners. Maintaining a basic, armed, around-the-clock two-person private security team costs about $11,000 per month. Government spending on rhino protection has not been quantified, but it possibly run to tens of millions of dollars. In 2011, 26 poachers were documented killed in firefights with authorities, and there’s every sign that more will die in 2012.

John Hume is South Africa’s largest private rhino owner, with more than 800 animals. He’s a leading proponent of legalizing the horn trade, reasoning that Asian buyers aren’t interested in rhinos, just their horns. So why not just periodically cut off their horns, leave the animals alive, and allow conservation to profit handsomely in the process? Hume’s proposal is appealing, but things aren’t quite so simple. Trade would have to be carefully regulated, and South African government agencies are often ineffective and corrupt (evidenced the number of police and national parks employees arrested for poaching). Key governments in Asia — China and Vietnam, in particular — are seen by many to be dragging their feet in taking decisive action to enforce existing CITES regulations, and it’s not clear that they’d be willing or able to control a formal market in horn.

As with other contraband, hard numbers on the illegal horn trade are elusive, and it’s not known if a legal industry could supply enough horn to reduce black market prices enough to disincentivize poachers. One estimate is that between 2.5 and 3.5 tons of rhino horn leaves South Africa every year, the product of poaching, the theft of display-mounted horns from museums, and “pseudohunts” like the one Lemtongthai conducted with the Thai sex workers.

The legalization debate would not be happening if there was an effective way of reducing demand among buyers. Conservationists disagree on why demand and poaching have risen so sharply since 2007, which makes formulating and coordinating an effective demand reduction strategy
Staff at the Vietnamese embassy in Pretoria have been found in possession of rhino horn.
extremely challenging. Some say the recent rush for rhino horn emanates from Vietnam, where, a few years ago, rumors circulated that a prominent politician had been cured of cancer by consuming it. Many Vietnamese researchers and journalists say that sprinkling powdered rhino horn on food, snorting it like cocaine or using it as a hangover remedy has become fashionable way of showing status among the nouveaux riches. Staff at the Vietnamese Embassy in Pretoria have been found in possession of horn and even filmed buying it by a South African TV crew in 2008.

Others contend that increased demand in China is the main reason for the poaching epidemic. Rhino horn has long been part of the pharmacopoeia of traditional Chinese medicine, which ascribes fever- and inflammation-reducing qualities to it. But China banned internal trade in rhino horn in the early 1990s and removed it from the official list of traditional medications under pressure from conservationists. At least one influential researcher theorizes that horn became progressively harder to buy after the domestic trade ban, and dealers’ stockpiles ran down, making what little horn remained in circulation increasingly expensive and fueling the expansion of poaching operations in Africa.

MORE FROM YALE e360

Fighting A Last-Ditch Battle
To Save the Rare Javan Rhino

Fighting A Last-Ditch Battle to Save the Rare Javan Rhino
Rhinoceroses worldwide are under siege as their habitat shrinks and poachers slaughter hundreds annually for their valuable horns. Now, in Indonesia, Rhett Butler reports, conservation groups are engaged in a desperate struggle to save the last 40 Javan rhinos on earth.
READ MORE
Other conservationists and researchers point to a 2008 report written by Jia Quin, a high-profile traditional Chinese medicine researcher, proposing the “sustainable utilization” of rhino horn and its re-legalization for medical use. Journalists have discovered that Jia is employed by Longhui, a subsidiary of a large Chinese firm called the Hawk Group, which is mainly a weapons manufacturer. Longhui has set up at least two rhino farms in China stocked with dozens of white rhino imported from South Africa. Longhui is controlled by powerful Communist Party politicians and has a clear interest in promoting the consumption of horn at the highest prices possible.

This high-profile push to promote horn consumption has many conservationists deeply worried. Some feel there will ultimately be no option but to legalize some form of horn trade to reduce poaching pressure. This will split Africa’s conservation community, many of whom feel that any legal trade will become a cover for illegal trade and that selling rhino horn as a valuable commodity is a tacit acknowledgment that it is in fact a useful medicine — exactly the opposite message than environmental groups have been trying to send.

Solutions to the rhino poaching problem will likely be complex and will test the resolve of conservationists and governments around the world. These magnificent, primeval beasts may only survive as semi-domesticated animals with defaced horns, under electronic monitoring and guarded around the clock.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Adam Welz is a South African writer, photographer and filmmaker based in Brooklyn, New York. His work includes an award-winning film about eccentric birders in New York City and exposés of environmental crime throughout southern Africa. Welz is a member of the Brooklyn Filmmakers Collective.
MORE BY THIS AUTHOR

SHARE: Tweet | Digg | Del.icio.us | Reddit | Mixx | Facebook | Stumble Upon

COMMENTS


Thank you Adam :)

The latest statistics are at 598 on the 27th Nov 2012 - a record number of poachings. You are welcome to join us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/oscap for the up to date stats and news. Or you are welcome to visit our website: www.oscap.co.za/.

Allison Thomson

Posted by Allison Thomson on 27 Nov 2012


Thank you Adam! Look me up on FB if you'd like to get something going out here. I'm having a banner made at the moment and am going to do a photo op soon. Anything I can do to help you on your end, please just ask.

Debbie Jane
Brooklyn, NY

Posted by Debbie Jane on 27 Nov 2012


Watch the 48-minute documentary, THE LAST RHINO, an Aljazeera English correspondent production that I directed and produced recently.

Posted by Clifford Bestall on 27 Nov 2012


This is a tragedy, and what makes it even more so is that President Jacob Zuma has failed to speak out against this poaching epidemic or to engage with the governments of countries like China, Vietnam and Korea on the issue. These iconic animals have become the latest casualty of the profound failure of governance in South Africa.

Posted by Lee Cahill on 27 Nov 2012


Thanks Adam.

There is a loud chorus for legalisation led by wildlife economists (http://www.rhino-economics.com/) but much uncertainty about the consequences. For example, if the price of horn dropped would that broaden the market beyond the available supply of legally traded horns. Private rhino farms might make a killing, so might the poachers.

Posted by Michael Cunningham on 28 Nov 2012


Vicuna story, described by CITES as one of the major conservation successes in the last 40 years and this is a perfect example and solution for our rhinos!

Posted by Albina Hume on 28 Nov 2012


Isn't there a way to synthesize rhino horns so people wouldn't be compelled to kill these amazing creatures?

Posted by janet on 29 Nov 2012


Despite numerous people quoting the Vicuna as a success story when it comes to trade a little deeper investigation will show that the Vicuna underwent a strict 30 year conservation period where no trade was allowed. Since trade has been opened it has become apparent that poaching is on the rise. Small time farmers/traders find that going through the "legal system" to get permits etc is far too cumbersome and are reverting to illegal trade. Hardly a good example for rhino horn trade!

Posted by Allison Thomson on 30 Nov 2012


One of the few sensible articles that considers most angles on this issue - well done. Here is an article worth reading on how to legalise the trade: http://www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2012/01/20/rhino-poaching-what-is-the-solution

One small technical point - poachers cannot use silenced rifles as you can only silence a sub sonic bullet from a small calibre rifle which would not be able to kill a rhino.

The spike in SA since 2008 was probably caused by a change in the regulations in SA when the rules made internal trade in horn illegal in SA. It was clear until then that a fair amount of horn from rhino that died of old age and broken horns etc. were finding their way within the country from the legal to the illegal trade and then to the markets. Once this avenue was stopped the only option for the illegal trade was to increase poaching. Approximately 500 rhino will die of old age alone every year but those horns now don't "find" their way to the markets easily now.

Posted by Kevin Leo-Smith on 30 Nov 2012


Janet, people would get the same "medicinal" effects from simply biting their own nails!

What we really need to find an alternative for is the position that traditional medicine has in these societies to remove these markets for Rhino horn, tigers, bear bile, birds' nests, etc.

Great article Adam, thanks for keeping the discussion going.

Posted by Babette on 30 Nov 2012


While I'm terribly disheartened by the record number of animals killed this year, I am pleased to see this discussion moving in new directions.

Thanks Adam.

Posted by Brendan Wenzel on 30 Nov 2012


Re comment by Kevin Leo-Smith about silenced rifles: There is, in fact, evidence that poachers are using silenced rifles to bring down rhino. Read here: http://killingforprofit.com/2012/11/05/farm-attack-gun-used-for-poaching/

Posted by Adam Welz on 30 Nov 2012


Great article Adam. Cheers. You might be interested to this quirky action from an artist in Grahamstown that is catching on here. Posting your hair, toenails, dogs toenails etc to the Chinese, Thai, Vietnamese embassies.

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/weird-wide-web/man-sends-toenails-chinese-embassy-protest-rhino-poaching-video

Posted by paddy on 30 Nov 2012


What can i say? Please say, "save all endangered species" like your most cherished pets! it is 'not' art to kill your most cherished pet!

And the world needs you to save the entire life giving planet, all its inhabitants, and procreation of all species!

To go global you need to rise above selfish perceptions and the change will always begin with how you live with 'yourself'...

Posted by patchur white on 30 Nov 2012


Thanks Adam for a well balanced article that will hopefully increase awareness around the world about the impending lose of these great animals.

Posted by Dalton Gibbs on 02 Dec 2012


Is there any way to persuade Asian governments to run advertising or educational campaigns telling people that there are no medicinal qualities to be gained from Rhino horn? I hate to say it but it is only going to get worse if the price of Rhino horn remains that high and the weapons and technology available to the poachers becomes even better. Tremendously sad, but brilliantly written article though.

Posted by Justin on 05 Dec 2012


Hi Justin

There have been a few attempts at persuading people that rhino horn is not medicine, or at least not particularly effective medicine, but none have so far gained much traction.

South Africa and Vietnam have, however, just signed a Memorandum of Understanding to co-operate on fighting wildlife crime. Vietnam has long avoided signing such documents, so this is a welcome development, although it remains to be seen if it'll be at all effective in curbing poaching.

My sources say that as of today, the 10th of December, 618 rhino have been poached in 2012 South Africa, by far the greatest annual number ever.

Posted by Adam Welz on 10 Dec 2012


To stop rhino poaching is fighting a (dirty) war.

To win you have to be ruthless and eventually reach for dirty means. I am convinced that decent means will NOt work. Suggestions were made to poison rhino horns and to make this known. If it is possible indeed to poison rhino horns without effect on the health of the animals I think it is legitimate, because our generation has a responsibility for future generations and conserving rhinos for future generations has priority over protecting the interests of horn users and capitalist criminals.

Posted by Frank Stavast on 13 Jan 2013


Adam,

Thanks for writing this. Our two young founders are also concerned about the fate of rhinos so they recently launched their Rhino letter Writing Campaign. Their goal was to collect 1,000 letters from people all over the world asking President Jacob Zuma to get serious about saving rhinos.

So far their campaign has received over 1,700 letters and more are coming in each day. The cut-off for submitting letters is April 1st. After that, our young founders will travel back to SA to hand deliver all the letters to President Zuma to show him that the whole world is begging him to save rhinos before it is too late.

You can learn more about their campaign and even send them your own letter at the link below:

http://onemoregeneration.org/2012/07/20/dear-president-zuma/

Thanks for caring and sharing from all of us at
OMG -)

Posted by Carter and Olivia on 02 Feb 2013


Why not just grind off all the rhinos horns and put fake ones on?

Posted by dale on 15 Mar 2013


My wish is that the whole world will stand together on the issue if saving the Rhino. Should we involve the workdwide Avaaz Campaigners?

Annelie

Posted by annelie franken on 03 Apr 2013



 

RELATED ARTICLES


How Drones Are Emerging As Valuable Conservation Tool
Lian Pin Koh believes drones can be a key part of conservation efforts, particularly in remote regions. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, he talks about how his project, ConservationDrones, is promoting the use of drones for everything from counting orangutans to stopping poaching.
READ MORE

Africa’s Vultures Threatened By An Assault on All Fronts
Vultures are being killed on an unprecedented scale across Africa, with the latest slaughter perpetrated by elephant poachers who poison the scavenging birds so they won’t give away the location of their activities.
READ MORE

Primate Rights vs Research: Battle in Colombian Rainforest
A Colombian conservationist has been locked in a contentious legal fight against a leading researcher who uses wild monkeys in his search for a malaria vaccine. A recent court decision that banned the practice is seen as a victory in efforts to restrict the use of monkeys in medical research.
READ MORE

Life on the Mississippi: Tale of the Lost River Shrimp
The 20th-century re-engineering of the Mississippi River wreaked havoc on natural systems and devastated once-abundant populations of native river shrimp. Biologist Paul Hartfield has focused his work on studying these creatures, which were known for making one of the world’s great migrations.
READ MORE

Brown Pelicans: A Test Case for The U.S. Endangered Species Act
Brown pelicans were removed from the U.S. Endangered Species List in 2009, in what was considered a major conservation success story. But a recent crash in Pacific Coast populations of sardines, the pelican’s prime food, is posing new threats to these oddly elegant birds.
READ MORE


SEARCH


Donate to Yale Environment 360


ABOUT

Menu

SUPPORT E360

Menu

TOPICS

Menu

DEPARTMENTS

Menu

HOME PAGE

Menu