16 Apr 2009: Analysis

Using Peer Pressure as a Tool
to Promote Greener Choices

Environmentalists, utilities, and green businesses are turning to behavioral economics to find innovative ways of influencing people to do the right thing when it comes to the environment. Is this approach really good for the planet or just a fad?

by richard conniff

Let’s say that every time you ride public transit, your fare card with its unique number also buys you a ticket to a periodic $50,000 lottery. Your number can turn up any day of the week, but you only win if you rode public transit that day. Think you might start taking public transit more often?

It’s an idea straight out of behavioral economics, an unconventional field of research that examines how human nature really works and uses it to shape the choices people make. The lottery idea, for instance, capitalizes on the human tendency to overvalue outcomes with extremely low probabilities, according to George Loewenstein, a behavioral economist at Carnegie Mellon University. The possibility of finding out that you missed the big payoff also exploits our innate regret aversion.

This new way of thinking about — and some would say manipulating — behavior is likely to be an important tool for addressing environmental issues over the next few years. Behavioral economics is the theory behind a variety of measures now being promoted by environmental groups, power companies, and green businesses — from smart meters for cutting electricity consumption to the use of social networks to promote weatherization.

The Obama White House is packed with true believers in behavioral economics, including economic advisor Austan Goolsbee, budget director Peter Orszag, and regulatory czar Cass Sunstein, a constitutional scholar
This new way of thinking about — and some would say manipulating — behavior is likely to be a key tool for addressing environmental issues.
and co-author of Nudge, a popular treatment of subtle ways to influence the choices people make. And while the Obama administration has yet to unveil environmental initiatives based on behavioral economics, Orzag recently told Time magazine, “It really applies to all the big areas where we need change."

For those who skipped Economics 101 — or took it before behavioral approaches began to coalesce into a theory in the 1980s — a primer is in order: Traditional economics holds that people act rationally. We sort through all available information, balance the pros and cons, and arrive at the best possible decision to maximize our own self-interest.

Behavioral economists say that we are quirkier and more complicated than that. Instead of carefully weighing the choices, we often make decisions based on gut instinct. Or we get overwhelmed and do nothing. We also do irrational things like acting altruistically toward total strangers. Unless you happen to be an economist, this may not come as news. Some psychologists carp that the economists are just putting a new spin on basic social psychology. But by any name, taking account of normal human tendencies promises a more realistic way of predicting and influencing how people act.

For instance, in one study, researchers asked each of four groups of utility customers to cut energy consumption for a different reason — the good of the planet, the well-being of future generations, the financial
‘People don’t just want to conserve energy,’ one psychologist says, ‘they want to be acknowledged for conserving energy.’
savings, or because their neighbors were doing it. By comparing electric meter readings, the researchers determined that only the last message had any effect, eliciting a 10 percent drop in consumption. A subsequent study found that when electric bills compared a customer’s energy consumption against the neighborhood average, profligate customers scaled back. In fact, the social norm was so powerful that thrifty customers also responded, by splurging. The weirdly effective fix was to add a smiley face to the thrifty bills — like a gold star from teacher.

“People don’t just want to conserve energy,” says Arizona State University psychologist Robert B. Cialdini, “they want to be acknowledged for conserving energy.”

A dozen utilities around the country have contracted with Positive Energy Inc., where Cialdini is a consultant, to use the billing technique. Cialdini is also testing the social norms approach to boost recycling and water conservation. He has found that even if most people in a community don’t actually practice water conservation, you can persuade them to reduce water use simply by telling them that their neighbors at least approve of the idea. “As long as you’re giving people honest information that they don’t already have,” he says, “this is not manipulation. This is education.”

One of the most successful experiments using the social norm dates back to the 1980s in Hood River, Ore., where local civic groups campaigned to enroll entire neighborhoods in a weatherization campaign, so contractors could move efficiently from house to house. “It wasn’t about the marketing budget,” says Ralph Cavanagh of the Natural Resources Defense Council, “it was about creating the impression that all your neighbors were doing it and that it was really unacceptable not to do it. If you didn’t do it, the Boy Scouts showed up at your door wondering what was going on.”

Despite original estimates that 20 to 30 percent of the 3,500 homes in Hood River would participate, the actual results were closer to 90 percent. Cavanagh says that officials from other areas in the U.S. have recently expressed interest in replicating the program.

Some behavioral tweaks — like giving people information in a form they can understand — might seem woefully obvious, except that hardly anyone does it. “Why is the electric meter on the outside of the house, and why is it in units that are meaningless to people?” asks Tony Leiserowitz, director of the Yale Project on Climate Change. “I don’t know what a kilowatt hour is. Why not display it in dollars?”

In some Alaskan communities, power companies install electric meters that require pre-payment with a credit card. Along with telling people how much they’re spending right now, these meters also tap into innate loss aversion, says Leiserowitz: “You’ve invested and want to keep it from running down to zero.” Electricity consumption typically drops 15 percent.

Because so much of the human brain is wired for sight, making consumption visible also works. A British startup, DIY Kyoto, is planning the U.S. launch later this year of its Wattson, a wireless device that displays electrical consumption both numerically and by glowing different colors, from blue to red, as usage increases. Customers can also toy with the social norm response by connecting to a website for comparisons with other Wattson owners.

Some approaches from behavioral economics aim to make pollution more painful — or at least to distribute the pain more equitably. For
Some approaches from behavioral economics aim to make pollution more painful — or at least to distribute the pain more equitably.
instance, in the current auto insurance system, you pay the same premium for driving 5,000 miles a year as your neighbor does for driving 30,000. An alternative approach, Pay As You Drive (PAYD) insurance, matches the premium to the mileage, as reported by GPS or periodic service station inspections. A recent Brookings Institution study calculated that PAYD would save money for two out of three U.S. households, reduce driving by 8 percent, and cut carbon emissions nationwide by 2 percent.

Other behavioral proposals involve making environmental choices painless to the point of being invisible. For instance, many airlines now encourage customers to mitigate the carbon footprint of a flight by buying offsets; it’s an opt-in system. But including the offsets in the ticket price — with customers free to opt out — would dramatically increase participation, and get Virgin Atlantic, say, a lot closer to bragging rights as a genuinely green airline.

Turning a green choice into a status symbol also motivates people disproportionately; in California, for instance, hybrid vehicles get to bypass traffic with a special label giving them access to High Occupancy Vehicle lanes.

Critics complain that behavioral solutions are often more cute or clever than effective, particularly given the scale of a problem like global warming. They tweak the system, but they can’t match $4-a-gallon gas for changing behavior. The influence of social norms, says Paul C. Stern of the National Research Council, tends to be demonstrated “on behaviors that have miniscule environmental effect, and it’s not clear how long the effect lasts.” A technological fix like installing a more efficient furnace, on the other hand, continues to work regardless of what the neighbors are up to.

But Stern acknowledges that weatherization programs with exactly the same incentives have elicited dramatically different consumer response, depending on how they are designed — witness the Oregon program. The trick, says George Loewenstein, is to take conventional economic tools like pricing, subsidies, technology, and taxation, and use behavioral thinking to “supercharge” the way they get delivered.

That may include reshaping the central message of the environmental movement itself. “We know from a lot of psychological research that people are loss averse,” says Leiserowitz, “and the environmental community has done a terrific job of depicting the problem in terms of loss — endangered species, climate change, deforestation. The flip side is that the environmental community has been pretty bad at describing solutions, which often get framed in terms of loss as well: Get rid of your car, turn down the heat, get by with less. It’s disempowering. It makes people give up and do nothing.”

Human nature demands a positive alternative, he says, like the British Transition Towns movement, in which residents of a community together devise a plan for greater resilience, and even happiness, in the face of climate change. For instance, Totnes, in Devon, uses its own currency to encourage reliance on local retailers, and has also developed community-wide campaigns for weatherization, energy-efficient lighting, tree-planting, and gardening. “Martin Luther King didn’t say ‘I have a nightmare,’” says Leiserowtiz. “He said, ‘I have a dream.’ And that’s what made people willing to put their bodies on the line, to bring that vision into being.”

The basic lesson from the behavioral approach, Leiserowitz says, is that the environmental movement also needs to present a vision, to show people what a sustainable world could look like, and what we can do now to make it a reality.

POSTED ON 16 Apr 2009 IN Climate Pollution & Health Sustainability Asia North America 

COMMENTS


Good to see this article! This is the concept behind City of Naperville, together with Partners for Clean Choice, making "Cool Ride-Clean Choice" window clings available for free to drivers of hybrid vehicles in Naperville, Ill.

Hybrids are often poorly marked as such, and our sticker is a soft peer pressure tool to help people spot hybrids on the road — in all their shapes and sizes.

I think of how the anti-smoking campaign has led to many states banning smoking in public buildings being an excellent example of the effects of peer pressure.

Now — if the feds could come up with some real incentives in their pending climate change legislation to encourage people to choose high mileage/low emissions vehicles per vehicle class.


Posted by Kate Delahunt Schrank on 16 Apr 2009


“Martin Luther King didn’t say ‘I have a nightmare,’” says Leiserowtiz. “He said, ‘I have a dream.’ And that’s what made people willing to put their bodies on the line, to bring that vision into being.”

Thanks, Richard Conniff, for reinforcing this truth.
Posted by TRB on 16 Apr 2009


Green is a religion so why not use religious principles like guilt to try and further coerce the public into going along. And if anyone thinks Pay as You Drive insurance scheme's are going to result in lower insurance bills, well, I have a bridge to sell you.

Posted by f1fan on 16 Apr 2009


You mention the British Transition Towns movement, "in which residents of a community together devise a plan for greater resilience, and even happiness." Readers may be interested in the idea of building new towns in the countryside in which people work part-time (18-to-24 hours a week) and in their free time build their own houses, cultivate gardens, and pursue other leisure-time activities. A Gallup poll found that 40 percent of the American people would either definitely or probably like to live this way with another 25 percent indicating possible interest. Industries might be interested because people can work faster and more efficiently for shorter periods of time than for longer, just as in track and field the short-distance runners always run faster than the long-distance runners.

Anyway, I have a book about the idea. It's called THE SOFT PATH: Notes for a New Way of Life in America, and is available online.
Posted by Luke Lea on 30 Apr 2009


Comments have been closed on this feature.
richard conniffABOUT THE AUTHOR
Richard Conniff is a 2007 Guggenheim Fellow and a National Magazine Award-winning writer, whose articles have appeared in Time, Smithsonian, The Atlantic, The New York Times Magazine, and National Geographic. His upcoming book, Swimming With Piranhas at Feeding Time: My Life Doing Dumb Stuff With Animals, is due out from W.W. Norton in May. He is the author of six other books, including The Natural History of the Rich: A Field Guide and Spineless Wonders: Strange Tales of the Invertebrate World. Conniff has also written for Yale Environment 360 about the pursuit of the carbon-neutral building and a green scorecard for rating U.S. economic stimulus projects.
MORE BY THIS AUTHOR

 
 

RELATED ARTICLES


As Arctic Ocean Ice Disappears,
Global Climate Impacts Intensify

The top of the world is turning from white to blue in summer as the ice that has long covered the north polar seas melts away. This monumental change is triggering a cascade of effects that will amplify global warming and could destabilize the global climate system.
READ MORE

What’s Killing Native Birds in
The Mountain Forests of Kauai?

Biologist Eben Paxton is sounding the alarm about the catastrophic collapse of native bird populations on the Hawaiian island of Kauai. His group's research has uncovered the culprit: disease-carrying mosquitoes that have invaded the birds' mountain habitat.
READ MORE

Why We Need a Carbon Tax,
And Why It Won’t Be Enough

Putting a price on carbon is an idea whose time has come, with even Big Oil signaling it may drop its long-standing opposition to a carbon tax. But the question is, has it come too late?
READ MORE

Clinton vs. Trump: A Sharp Divide
Over Energy and the Environment


READ MORE

How Climate Change Could Jam
The World's Ocean Circulation

Scientists are closely monitoring a key current in the North Atlantic to see if rising sea temperatures and increased freshwater from melting ice are altering the “ocean conveyor belt” — a vast oceanic stream that plays a major role in the global climate system.
READ MORE

 

MORE IN Analysis


As Arctic Ocean Ice Disappears,
Global Climate Impacts Intensify

by peter wadhams
The top of the world is turning from white to blue in summer as the ice that has long covered the north polar seas melts away. This monumental change is triggering a cascade of effects that will amplify global warming and could destabilize the global climate system.
READ MORE

How Climate Change Could Jam
The World's Ocean Circulation

by nicola jones
Scientists are closely monitoring a key current in the North Atlantic to see if rising sea temperatures and increased freshwater from melting ice are altering the “ocean conveyor belt” — a vast oceanic stream that plays a major role in the global climate system.
READ MORE

Wildlife Farming: Does It Help
Or Hurt Threatened Species?

by richard conniff
Wildlife farming is being touted as a way to protect endangered species while providing food and boosting incomes in rural areas. But some conservation scientists argue that such practices fail to benefit beleaguered wildlife.
READ MORE

What Would a Global Warming
Increase of 1.5 Degrees Be Like?

by fred pearce
The Paris climate conference set the ambitious goal of finding ways to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, rather than the previous threshold of 2 degrees. But what would be the difference between a 1.5 and 2 degree world? And how realistic is such a target?
READ MORE

After Paris, A Move to Rein In
Emissions by Ships and Planes

by fred pearce
As the world moves to slash CO2 emissions, the shipping and aviation sectors have managed to remain on the sidelines. But the pressure is now on these two major polluting industries to start controlling their emissions at last.
READ MORE

Abrupt Sea Level Rise Looms
As Increasingly Realistic Threat

by nicola jones
Ninety-nine percent of the planet's freshwater ice is locked up in the Antarctic and Greenland ice caps. Now, a growing number of studies are raising the possibility that as those ice sheets melt, sea levels could rise by six feet this century, and far higher in the next, flooding many of the world's populated coastal areas.
READ MORE

How Nations Are Chipping
Away at Their Protected Lands

by richard conniff
Winning protected status for key natural areas and habitat has long been seen as the gold standard of conservation. But these gains are increasingly being compromised as governments redraw park boundaries to accommodate mining, logging, and other development.
READ MORE

Can We Reduce CO2 Emissions
And Grow the Global Economy?

by fred pearce
Surprising new statistics show that the world economy is expanding while global carbon emissions remain at the same level. Is it possible that the elusive “decoupling” of emissions and economic growth could be happening?
READ MORE

On Fuel Economy Efforts,
U.S. Faces an Elusive Target

by marc gunther
One of President Obama’s signature achievements on climate has been strict standards aimed at improving auto fuel efficiency to nearly 55 miles per gallon by 2025. But credits and loopholes, coupled with low gas prices, may mean the U.S. will fall well short of this ambitious goal.
READ MORE

New Green Challenge: How to
Grow More Food on Less Land

by richard conniff
If the world is to have another Green Revolution to feed its soaring population, it must be far more sustainable than the first one. That means finding ways to boost yields with less fertilizer and rethinking the way food is distributed.
READ MORE


e360 digest
Yale
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies
.

SEARCH e360



Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter


CONNECT


ABOUT

About e360
Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


DEPARTMENTS

Opinion
Reports
Analysis
Interviews
Forums
e360 Digest
Podcasts
Video Reports

TOPICS

Biodiversity
Business & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Urbanization
Water

REGIONS

Antarctica and the Arctic
Africa
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

“video
Tribal people and ranchers join together to stop a project that would haul coal across their Montana land.
Watch the video.

e360 MOBILE

Mobile
The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 PHOTO ESSAY

“Alaska
An aerial view of why Europe’s per capita carbon emissions are less than 50 percent of those in the U.S.
View the photos.

e360 VIDEO

“Ugandan
Ugandan scientists monitor the impact of climate change on one of Africa’s most diverse forests and its extraordinary wildlife.
Learn more.

e360 VIDEO

Food waste
An e360 video series looks at the staggering amount of food wasted in the U.S. – a problem with major human and environmental costs.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.

e360 SPECIAL REPORT

“Tainted
A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

OF INTEREST



Yale