05 Apr 2011: Interview

A Scientist Extols the Value
Of Forests Shaped by Humans

Political ecologist Susanna Hecht has incurred the wrath of some conservationists by arguing that the notion of the primeval forest is largely a myth and that disturbed forests play a vital ecological function. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, she makes the case for a “new rurality” that places less emphasis on protected forests and more on the areas where people live.

by john carey

Susanna Hecht didn’t set out to make waves in the conservation community when she traveled to El Salvador in 1999 to help the government with its environmental plan. At the time, the conventional wisdom was that the country was an environmental wasteland, a cautionary example of the devastating effects of deforestation.

But Hecht, a professor of political ecology at the University of California, Los Angeles, didn’t see a ruined landscape. Instead, she saw luxuriant “living fences” between properties, ribbons of forest along rivers, coffee plantations shaded by forest canopies, and whole new woodlands springing from abandoned fields. But were these forests merely overlooked, or were they making a true comeback? Using satellite photographs, Hecht and a colleague found a striking change: The amount of land with at least 30 percent tree cover had jumped by 22 percent from the early 1990s to the early 2000s “Many analysts have failed to note the extent of woodland recuperation,” they reported in a landmark 2007 paper in BioScience.

Susanna Hecht
UCLA
Susanna Hecht
Since then, Hecht has returned to El Salvador many times, most recently in early March. Her nuanced studies of humanity’s interaction with forests have revealed how major social forces, such as globalization, affect our environment. For example, not only were imports of cheap food replacing the traditional subsistence agricultural system in El Salvador, but El Salvadorans who had migrated to the U.S. also were sending back large amounts of money — so-called remittances — to their families at home. That made it possible for people to buy food instead of growing their own, allowing farmland to revert to forest.

In an interview with Yale Environment 360, Hecht argues that it’s time to start thinking about a new conservation strategy for the world’s forests. Instead of working mostly to set aside preserves and parks for wildlife and biodiversity, we need to focus more on the unprotected areas where people live. She talks about a “new rurality,” wringing the most biodiversity from a patchwork landscape of crops, pastures, agroforestry plantations, and abandoned farmland reverting to forest. And in her latest work with the El Salvadoran government, she is focusing on yet another role for this rural landscape — helping to adapt to climate change.

“There has been a recognition that inhabited environments can have major conservation values,” Hecht told Yale e360 contributor John Carey. “If we have lots of people with forests we should be thrilled. And we should be really thrilled when the forest comes back, because we have a narrative that it doesn’t.”

Yale Environment 360: Let’s start with your first trip to El Salvador. What did you see?

Susanna Hecht: Well, anyone who teaches tropical ecology has been exposed to various lines that say nature has been extinguished in El Salvador. It’s been a place that’s been a Malthusian poster child since the 1970s. The dense population and the limited resource base seemed to create this idea that if you had people and you had forest then pretty soon you would have no forest and a lot of people.

In 1999, I was asked to come down to help them think about the vision for El Salvador for the 2020s, and also to work on legal codes and regulations. As I was being picked up at the airport and driven to the hotel, there was a big apologia. They said, ‘It’s really too bad — we just don’t have any forests.’

And I was quite perplexed because it was clear there were a lot of agro forests and secondary forests along the road. It wasn’t this blasted landscape that one had been inclined to imagine. It had people, but it also had lots of different kinds of forest.

e360: So being a scientist, you decided to see whether forests were indeed making a comeback in the country?

Hecht: It was because people kept saying there weren’t any forests, yet I’d seen them with my own eyes. So with Sassan Saatchi, I said let’s take a look at this with satellite imagery. Because it was a war zone for a long
There has been an extraordinary recovery of forests — it wasn’t that I had trees painted on my glasses.”
time, there was a large and extensive archive of images. What we discovered was that there had been an extraordinary recovery of forest in these areas. It wasn’t that I had trees painted on the front of my sunglasses.

Most people thought I was relatively delusional, but the other thing that has been transpiring is that many observers in many parts of the world have been noticing this process of forest recovery as well.

e360: What is the cause of the forest recovery?

Hecht: Well, in El Salvador, part of it could be explained through migration — migration to the United States and some urban migration. But what was important was that the population density was as high as it had been when the area was being completely deforested. So you couldn’t say it was a Malthusian process. You had to say something had changed about the political ecology.

And partly this is a function of globalization. With globalization and structural adjustment programs, things like corn and other basic staples were coming in at import prices that were below the cost of their production in El Salvador. That meant if you were going to sell your corn, you would be selling it at a loss. So peasant agriculture soon collapsed, allowing reforestation.

Another thing about globalization is that for niche commodities it’s quite good. Those are crops that get a premium. What it meant in the case of El Salvador is that things like cashews and coffee and artisanal products made from wood had a vigorous market compared to the crummy returns you got for corn and the milpa crops [Subsistence crops such as beans and squash.] There was a shift to higher value crops, many of them arboreal.

I was driving around a lot this last week in El Salvador, and in areas where even a decade ago you’d still see a lot of milpa up on these steep slopes, you really didn’t see it anymore.

e360: With people buying more imported food rather than growing it themselves, how can they afford it?

Hecht: More than half the households receive remittances from various countries, mostly from family members in the Los Angeles area. People work at jobs here in the U.S. and send money back. If you are getting remittances, you live a lot better — it basically doubles your income. Instead of having to produce corn with low yields on, say, steep slopes, you could buy the corn for the tortillas and not have to go into these forest areas. The result was a lot of land abandonment. The land was allowed to go into successional activities or forest-based economies rather than being used for producing basically corn.

e360: How much money is flowing into these countries?

Click to enlarge
El Salvador Forest

BioScience
Changes in forest cover by decade in El Salvador, from the 1990s to the 2000s.
Hecht: There has been a major structural change in these economies and essentially they have to be seen as being highly globalized. They are run, in part, though large remittances. If we were to think about it globally, we would be looking at about 10 percent of the world’s population and something like $320 billion a year flowing through these informal channels to households to improve their well-being. So in a certain sense what you see in these areas is that they are less producers of commodities than they are generating services through providing a sort of refuge for households in times of stress. And they are increasingly maintaining biodiversity services and carbon absorption services, for which they are not paid.

e360: Are these global forces driving forest recovery in countries other than El Salvador?

Hecht: We are beginning to see a lot of forest recovery in lots of places. One salient place is the United States, although the mechanisms are somewhat different here. In the Sahel, more than two million hectares have been recuperated because of women planting tree crops and families receiving remittances from men who have migrated. You also see the rise of really high-value tree crops that have taken over areas that used to be in pasture in Amazonia.

Overall, around the world, we are seeing a net increase in forest cover. We’re seeing not just a forest recovery, but declines in deforestation as well. I think this is a ‘good news’ story.

e360: This raises the thorny question of whether or not these rural areas, which have lots of people along with the reforested areas, really do have any conservation value. Do they? And might saying that forests are recovering cause people to say that we no longer need to worry about deforestation? I heard that when your 2007 paper came out, there was quite a reaction.

Hecht: It pissed off a lot of people. I had 700 emails screaming at me for promoting deforestation. On the other hand, others said: Thank God someone is talking about the forest recovery.

I am always surprised how controversial this is. I think it’s partly because some conservationists don’t count secondary forest as real forest. They see forests as ahistorical and apolitical, and the forests just aren’t. It was pounded into people in Bio 101 that human interaction with forests is destructive. But there has been extensive human influence even in places like the Amazon. What my work there taught me is that these places weren’t empty, and that if you only look at the ecological side, you don’t see the social side of forests. The conservationists really don’t like this.

What helped me to see forests in degraded areas was being around people messing in the forest. So I was primed to see the El Salvador forests and not to disparage them. To me there is almost no primary forest; it’s all secondary forests. All landscapes will have to be working landscapes. If we have lots of people with forests, we should be thrilled. And we should be really thrilled when the forest comes back because we have a narrative that it doesn’t come back.

e360: But are these secondary forests valuable?

Hecht: There has been a recognition that inhabited environments can have major conservation value. Even though the reforested areas are fragmented, they are quite diverse in terms of landscape. They end up
Hedgerows, woodlots, gardens and domestic forests all end up supporting biodiversity in surprising ways.”
actually having a rather interesting impact at regional levels — they scale up rather better than one might imagine. Even those hedgerows can provide something like 40 to 50 percent of the biodiversity that you get in a riparian system in El Salvador. And hedgerows, land demarcations, woodlots, gardens and domestic forests of various kinds all end up supporting biodiversity in ways that are kind of surprising. For instance, the bird diversity of El Salvador is about equal to that of Belize, which has a fraction of the population and far less fragmented forests.

Given the kind of magnitude of the changes that are coming no matter what, you need to have more access to more different kinds of conservation landscapes than merely the large-scale set-aside. A lovely conservation area can lose its virtue simply because of strong climate change.

e360: Which brings us to your most recent visit to El Salvador, working with the country on responding the threat of climate change. It sounds like they are taking this threat far more seriously than we are in the U.S., and that secondary forests can play a major role?

Hecht: El Salvador and Central America take climate change seriously because they are getting nailed by these intense storms. As I always say, I never thought the future would come so soon. Last year El Salvador got hit so badly that the cost of recovering from storms and floods was much more than the costs of recuperating landscapes to build in more resilience to climate change. Now they see adaptation as the primary goal — it is the cost-effective thing to do.

MORE FROM YALE e360

Deep in Ecuador’s Rainforest,
A Plan to Forego an Oil Bonanza

Deep in Ecuador’s Rainforest, a Plan to Forego an Oil Bonanza
Ecuador’s Yasuni National Park is one of the most biodiverse places on Earth and is home to remote Indian tribes. It also sits atop a billion barrels of oil. Now, Ecuador and the United Nations are forging an ambitious plan to walk away from drilling in the park in exchange for payments from the international community.
READ MORE
Maintaining arboreal vegetation helps build resilience to climate change, and also brings slope protection, water channel protection, and tidal surge protection. In fact, the national climate policy of El Salvador essentially invokes the idea of agroforestry and forestry activities as a means of adapting to climate change — and of contributing to larger scale mitigation. Their economic and ecological development programs are now one and the same. For them, climate change isn’t an abstraction or something that you debate in Congress.

Lamentably, the United States has lost its legitimacy in dealing with climate change because it has cut its funding for it and pretends it’s not going on. Other countries lack the luxury to do so. They are taking it seriously and using everything they can.

And at the same time, these complex inhabited landscapes provide complex habitat over large areas linking different kinds of land uses for conservation ends. And I believe, with E.O. Wilson, that there is a kind of a biophilia. People like biodiversity in their heart of hearts when they’re not obsessed with controlling everything and turning it into a uniform place.

POSTED ON 05 Apr 2011 IN Biodiversity Forests Policy & Politics Policy & Politics Central & South America 

COMMENTS


Excellent post.

Without forests, we wouldn't have air to breathe, our soils wouldn't have the nutrients to grow, and the animals that make up a part of our ecosystem wouldn't exist.

In an effort to balance out the needs of people and the needs of forests, scientists, conservationists, and wood and paper industry owners got together in 1994 and developed what they called the Sustainable Forestry Initiative. This agreement worked out principles that "call for a land stewardship ethic which integrates the reforestation, nurturing, and harvesting of trees for useful products with the conservation of soil, air and water resources, wildlife and fish habitat, and forest aesthetics." Basically, this means that even though we will continue to harvest trees from our forests, we will try to be as careful as possible not to disturb the environment and the species who live there.

Greenery protects the eye and maintains ecological balance. There are vast tracts of wasteland. Can’t something be exploited from it? There are many trees which thrive under a variety of environment conditions with less water. There is Annona Squamosa (Custard Apple. The fruit has pulp which can be canned and soft drinks made from it. The seed yield about 30 per cent oil which is toxic and can be used as natural pesticide. The oil in general is used in paints and varnishes. The residue after extraction of oil can be used as natural fertilizer.

There is Agave Americana ,every part of the plant can be put to use. It requires very little water and it regenerates. It has cellulose and can be used as input in paper making. Fermentable sugars in the plant can lead to Biofuel production. The fibre is used in rope making. In Philippines people use the fibre in garments which are sold under the trade name DIP DRY. The specialty of these fabrics is that water won’t stick to it. A steroid HECOGENEIN can be obtained from the plant. Since on putrification methane is generated, the plant cut into pieces can be utilised in Biogas production. In Kenya people cut the plant leaves into pieces and dry them and mix them in concrete since it has strong fibres.

Indeed Multiple use plants are the answer for afforestation which can have LEAF TO ROOT APPROACH.

Dr.A.Jagadeesh Nellore (AP), India
E-mail: anumakonda.jagadeesh@gmail.com

Posted by Dr.A.Jagadeesh on 21 Apr 2011


Thanks for a really great interview. As a permaculturalist, I really appreciate such a robust
approach to agroecosystems and conservation / climate change adaptation.

Thanks again,

Harry
Peacetree Permaculture
http://www.ptpc.com.au

Posted by Harry Wykman on 12 May 2011


I found this interview and the paper really interesting. Here in Europe there is a very ill-informed debate about 'wilderness' and the desirability of returning large areas of land to it - whatever it is! Many people really do not understand the historic cultural landscape sufficiently to appreciate that their 'wilderness' is nothing of the sort. The debate is more about psychology than ecology.

Our wildlife now inhabits cultural landscapes and this wildlife includes old growth species, which now primarily occupy wood pasture systems (historic agro-forestry), many of which are no longer actively managed and are declining in quality as a result. Our knowledge of the ecology of these old growth species suggests that wood-pastures are structurally very similar to the original natural forest cover, and that people merely occupied and adapted the natural open forest areas. Where human tree management was compatible then these species survived. Indeed, there is little evidence of mass extinctions of old growth species within Britain (where I live). Admitedly data is rather thin, but the indications are that people and old growth species can co-exist to a considerable extent. Unfortunately the debate is blurred by too many assumptions, too many unproven hypotheses treated as fact, but perhaps the European experience is relevent to tropical forest situations, to some extent?

Dr Keith Alexander
Ancient Tree Forum, UK

Posted by Keith Alexander on 13 May 2011


In the tropics forest are far from urban areas and their access is difficult. Endangered lowland species need to be reintroduced in urban areas. It is not just a matter about "going green" mainstreaming plant taxonomy in the society is needed.

Collaborative tree mapping could be a way to achieve this as it gives a visibility to the people's
knowledge.

You can contribute to it on the following website http://pericopsis.org/

Posted by Jean Weber on 16 Oct 2011


As a Salvadoran, I'm an emigrant myself. I also run an online newspaper for Salvadoran migrants, http://www.hermanoscercanos.com

Through my experience I can testify to the veracity of her finding that the increase in remittances lead to reduced farmland use. I think this is great for reforestation, although it also leads to a heavy reliance on cash crops like coffee and cashews, as is mentioned in the article.

Although these are arboreal plantations, a lot of pesticides are still in use. I know this first-hand, as I know coffee producers and pickers who have suffered from the ill effects of these chemicals. This is slowly changing though.

I'm a fan of her work and ideas, and commend the steadfastness needed to maintain her position in the face of criticism.

Posted by Jorge Valle on 29 May 2012


Comments have been closed on this feature.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
John Carey, who conducted this interview for Yale Environment 360, is a freelance writer covering the environment, energy, science, technology and medicine. Until this year, he was senior correspondent at BusinessWeek. He is a former editor of The Scientist, and spent six years at Newsweek, where he covered science, technology, and health. In earlier articles for Yale Environment 360, he has written about the true costs of climate change and how failure to pass climate legislation will affect the green tech sector.
MORE BY THIS AUTHOR

 
 

RELATED ARTICLES


The High Environmental Cost
Of Illicit Marijuana Cultivation

Marijuana growers are ravaging forests in northern California to produce their lucrative crop. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, biologist Mary Power talks about the massive ecological footprint of marijuana growing and why nationwide legalization could help alleviate it.
READ MORE

Resilience: A New Conservation
Strategy for a Warming World

As climate change puts ecosystems and species at risk, conservationists are turning to a new approach: preserving those landscapes that are most likely to endure as the world warms.
READ MORE

On an Unspoiled Caribbean Isle,
Grand Plans for Big Tourist Port

East Caicos is a tropical jewel – the largest uninhabitated island in the Caribbean and home to rare birds and pristine turtle-nesting beaches. But plans for a giant port for cruise and cargo ships could change it forever.
READ MORE

A Grassroots Effort to Save
Africa’s Most Endangered Ape

The Cross River gorilla population in equatorial Africa has been pushed to the brink of extinction. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, a Nigerian scientist working to save the gorillas describes how local villagers are vital to protecting these apes.
READ MORE

As Andes Warm, Deciphering
The Future for Tropical Birds

Scientists have theorized that tropical birds in mountainous regions will move uphill as the climate warms. But new research in the Peruvian Andes suggests that the birds will stay put and face a new threat — predator snakes that will climb into their territory to escape the heat.
READ MORE

 

MORE IN Interviews


The High Environmental Cost
Of Illicit Marijuana Cultivation

by diane toomey
Marijuana growers are ravaging forests in northern California to produce their lucrative crop. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, biologist Mary Power talks about the massive ecological footprint of marijuana growing and why nationwide legalization could help alleviate it.
READ MORE

How Can We Make People
Care About Climate Change?

by richard schiffman
Norwegian psychologist Per Espen Stoknes has studied why so many people have remained unconcerned about climate change. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, he talks about the psychological barriers to public action on climate and how to overcome them.
READ MORE

Why a Leading Indian Politician
Is Now an Environmental Hawk

by christian schwagerl
Former Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh believes the “cult” of unfettered economic growth has been ruinous for India’s environment. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he talks about his vision of “green growth,” which he says is essential for his nation’s future.
READ MORE

Cloning a Mammoth: Science
Fiction or Conservation Tool?

by diane toomey
Biologist Beth Shapiro has published a new book that looks at the many questions – both technical and ethical – surrounding any attempt to revive extinct species. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, she explains why she believes new genetic technology could benefit critical ecosystems.
READ MORE

A New Face at the Helm of
The Oldest U.S. Green Group

by diane toomey
The Sierra Club has chosen Aaron Mair as its president, the first African-American to lead the largest U.S. environmental organization. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he talks about the lack of diversity in the environmental movement and what can be done to change that.
READ MORE

A Grassroots Effort to Save
Africa’s Most Endangered Ape

by john c. cannon
The Cross River gorilla population in equatorial Africa has been pushed to the brink of extinction. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, a Nigerian scientist working to save the gorillas describes how local villagers are vital to protecting these apes.
READ MORE

How British Columbia Gained
By Putting a Price on Carbon

by diane toomey
Seven years ago, British Columbia became the first jurisdiction in North America to adopt an economy-wide carbon tax. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, economics expert Stewart Elgie explains how the tax helped cut the province’s fossil fuel use without hurting its economy.
READ MORE

Oklahoma’s Clear Link Between
Earthquakes and Energy Boom

by diane toomey
Oklahoma officials this week said oil and gas activity was the likely cause of the stunning increase in earthquakes in the state. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, Oklahoma geologist Todd Halihan talks about what has caused this growing problem and what can be done about it.
READ MORE

For Buddhist Leader, Religion
And the Environment Are One

by roger cohn
As a Tibetan Buddhist leader, the Karmapa is promoting green practices in monasteries in the Himalayan region. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he talks about how the world needs both religion and science in tackling the “environmental emergency” of climate change.
READ MORE

Why This Tea Party Leader Is
Seeing Green on Solar Energy

by diane toomey
As a founder of the Tea Party movement, Debbie Dooley may be an unlikely advocate for renewable energy. But in an e360 interview, she explains why she is breaking ranks with fellow conservatives and promoting a Florida ballot initiative that would allow homeowners to sell power produced by rooftop solar.
READ MORE


e360 digest
Yale
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies
.

SEARCH e360



Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter

CONNECT


ABOUT

About e360
Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


DEPARTMENTS

Opinion
Reports
Analysis
Interviews
Forums
e360 Digest
Podcasts
Video Reports

TOPICS

Biodiversity
Business & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Urbanization
Water

REGIONS

Antarctica and the Arctic
Africa
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America

e360 PHOTO GALLERY

“Peter
Photographer Robert Wintner documents the exquisite beauty and biodiversity of Cuba’s coral reefs, which are largely intact thanks to stifled coastal development in the communist nation.
View the gallery.

e360 MOBILE

Mobile
The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 VIDEO

Warriors of Qiugang
The Warriors of Qiugang, a Yale Environment 360 video, chronicles a Chinese village’s fight against a polluting chemical plant. It was nominated for a 2011 Academy Award for Best Documentary Short.
Watch the video.


header image
Top Image: aerial view of Iceland. © Google & TerraMetrics.

e360 SPECIAL REPORT

“Tainted
A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

OF INTEREST



Yale