20 Dec 2010: Report

In China, a New Transparency
On Government Pollution Data

The Chinese government has begun to make environmental records available to the public, empowering green groups and citizens as they try to force factories — and the Western companies they supply — to comply with the law.

by christina larson

For several years, a tannery on the outskirts of Shanghai belched dark gases and odors into the air and dumped wastewater into a nearby waterway. The facility, operated by the Fuguo company in Shanghai’s Dachang district, processed leather used in hiking boots for the outdoors retailer Timberland, among other products. This was, needless to say, at odds with Timberland’ s catalogue image of blue skies and clear rivers and hikers frolicking in pristine wilderness, but it was all too common for China.

What wasn’t so common was that in September 2009, the factory operator invited members of the community to a meeting inside the factory, where residents, local media, and Timberland representatives came to share concerns. Fuguo’s CEO listened to impassioned complaints about noxious odors and local residents’ dizzy spells; a community representative was selected to channel future complaints. In April 2010, the facility underwent an inspection by a third-party auditor, with oversight by local environmental groups and community members, to confirm that it had indeed taken the steps it claimed to reduce emissions.

This didn’t happen without prodding. In the months prior to the meeting at the factory, Fuguo’s management had been contacted by an environmental lawyer acting on behalf of a local resident and then by a coalition of 18 Chinese environmental groups, known as the Green Choice Alliance. The activists were armed with records from the local environmental protection bureau documenting instances between 2004 and 2009 in which the factory had been found in violation of China’s own pollution laws. The salient fact is that they had the data.

Ma Jun
Getty Images
Former journalist Ma Jun founded a Beijing-based organization that has created a database of pollution records.
The notion of public access to environmental records in China, which enabled this campaign, is fairly new. By no means is public access complete — or uniformly implemented — across China. In a country where secrecy has long been the norm, vast exceptions restrict the release of any data categorized under the broad, vague category of “state secrets.” Yet it’s significant that the Chinese government has begun to experiment with making certain information available to the public.

“The conventional wisdom is that China is not transparent,” says Alex Wang, a senior attorney with the Natural Resource Defense Council’s Beijing Office. “But over the last few years, China has made meaningful progress on environmental transparency. China right now is behind the world standard overall, yet there really has been encouraging progress.”

In other words, one’s assessment depends on the benchmark for comparison — China is far behind most Western countries (the United States’ Toxic Release Inventory program began in the 1980s), but more transparent, at least in terms of pollution records, than a decade ago.

China’s first environmental agency, modeled in some ways on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), was created in 1993, one year after the Rio Earth Summit. Its early approach to environmental regulation was, not surprisingly, command and control. In 2003, a law requiring that environmental impact assessments be provided to the public before ground was broken on large infrastructure projects, was, as Wang puts it, a “significant milestone” for China, even though only an abridged version of the assessment was required, and not a lot of raw data. Further regulations passed in 2007, which went into effect in May 2008, called for local environmental protection departments to establish offices to make available to the public certain categories of pollution records. Meanwhile, some local environmental bureaus, for example in the northeastern rustbelt city of Shenyang, have been experimenting with offering more records than the national statutes require.

The fact that the government has begun to trickle out certain types of pollution records was noteworthy. But unless they were gathered together and made accessible, it would be hard for anyone to do much with them.

That was the niche that Ma Jun, a former journalist, saw in 2006 when he founded the Institute for Public and Environmental Affairs (IPE), one of the partners in Green Choice Alliance. After traveling around China, reporting on the nation’s environmental problems for the relatively liberal
‘To have meaningful public participation, the public first needs access to reliable information,’ says Ma Jun.
South China Morning Post throughout the 1990s and then penning the seminal 1999 book, China’s Water Crisis, Ma decided to shift gears from reporting on the problem to trying to fix it.

“I believe in engaging the public. But in order to have meaningful public participation, the public first needs access to reliable information. That is the first step,” the spritely Ma, in his mid-40s, told me in May when I visited him in Beijing. We were sitting inside his sparsely decorated office, its main feature a wooden bookshelf containing such titles as Retreat of the Elephants, an environmental history of China, and Malcolm Gladwell’s Tipping Point.

Behind us, in a second room, was a small cluster of computers, where his young staffers were entering database records, or reviewing documentation of factories’ environmental audits. It was a far cry from the dramatic countercultural sit-ins of America’s 1970s Earth Day activism, with which Ma, a former Yale University fellow, was also familiar. This disciplined, orderly review of documents and inputting data, however, is on the front lines of how China’s environmental advocates are finding relative success. “We cannot fight with slogans or poems,” he told me. “We must fight with data.”

For five years, with the assistance of a carefully cultivated network of young activists across the country, Ma’s team in Beijing has been collecting pollution records that were made available by local environmental protection bureaus, printed in state-run newspapers, or discovered from other sources. His database now includes some 70,000 records of factories violating the law. (Despite the appearance of efficient all-powerful one-party state, the truth is that China’s system of enforcement is fairly decentralized and often inefficient, except on security issues.)

China Water Pollution Map
China Water Pollution Map
The online China Water Pollution Map tracks water quality and pollution across China. Visit the site
Ma then took that data and put it online — into a series of free public databases, the most prominent known as the China Water Pollution Map. The central government has not shut down Ma’s four-year-old site, in part because, as he points out, he’s currently only arguing for the law to be upheld. “Before we can push for higher pollution standards,” he told me, a thoughtful glint in his eye, “we first want to have the existing regulations observed.”

With the data accessible, the next step was to getting people to use it. In 2008, Ma’s nonprofit joined with the Beijing-based nonprofit Friends of Nature and other like-minded groups to launch the Green Choice Alliance, which has been contacting multinational companies like Timberland to make them aware of their suppliers’ available pollution records. It was a lawyer affiliated with Friends of Nature that first helped the residents near the Shanghai tannery document and articulate their concerns.

A decade ago, large multinational companies that subcontracted to Asian factories to do, literally, their dirty work in assembling tennis shoes, T-shirts and TVs — and now iPhones and digital cameras — could claim that often they didn’t know what happened inside the factories their sub-contractors managed. It wasn’t an excuse entirely without justification. Once- or twice-yearly audits couldn’t catch everything. And after all, China had emissions standards on the books. If the local government didn’t adequately enforce those laws, how was a distant corporate executive to know? Now that excuse is less valid.

One company that has begun to use Ma’s database to identify factories that might have problems is Nike. The footwear and apparel company has 134 factories in China (about 330 if you count material suppliers). As May Qiu, Nike’s Guangzhou-based Asia Health, Safety and Environment manager, told me: “In the Nike supply chain, we don’t have our own factories, but we
Apple Computer is among the companies least responsive to working with Green Choice Alliance.
work with factories in our supply chain and want to ensure they meet these [environmental, health, and safety] requirements. We first got to know Mr. Ma Jun and IPE in the middle of 2008. We decide to use his databases to check our factories in the supply chain.” Nike oversees its own audits, but Qiu says the database is helpful for flagging potential violators and focusing resources. She did not say if any factories had lost contracts due to violations, but said Nike did plan “to integrate sustainable goals into sourcing decisions” in the future. “It’s better for us to manage and protect risk in our supply chain at the outset to protect our brand,” she explained.

Other companies that have shown an interest in working with the Green Choice Alliance include Wal-mart and General Electric. The German company Siemens has agreed to build up a tracking mechanism to compare its suppliers with the pollution databases. What those companies will do with information that factories in their supply chain have past violations isn’t yet clear, but taking steps to set up these checks is a positive preliminary step.

Among the companies least responsive to working with the Green Choice Alliance is Apple Computer, Inc. “Apple’s supplier base is the most difficult for us to figure out; they manage that in a highly secretive way — they never talk about who are their suppliers,” says Ma. “I think Apple probably has two faces: In America, it’s a very green friendly company, but in China, when it comes to its secret supply chain management, it’s a totally different thing.”

Because Apple treats its supply chain as privileged corporate information, it is difficult to trace factories it uses. Yet anecdotal information indicates problems: In October, a reporter from the Australian Broadcast Company visited the Number Five People’s Hospital in Suzhou and spoke with former workers in a plant that manufactured products for Apple. The workers said they had been made very ill, even unable to walk, after being exposed to a
The long-term battle is about building a system in China that is more transparent and open.
toxic chemical, n-hexane, in a compound used to wipe down touch-screens of iPhones.

A representative from Apple’s corporate communications office said in a voicemail that Apple is committed to responsible supply-chain management and referred me to Apple’s “Supplier Responsibility, 2010 Progress Report.” The document, posted online, sets forth the objective that “companies we do business with must provide safe working conditions, treat workers with dignity and respect, and use environmentally responsible manufacturing processes wherever Apple products are made.”

Ma’s contention is that companies, including Apple, can better ensure that the reality on the factory floor matches their lofty mission statements through more transparent oversight processes. “Apple by itself cannot overcome such great challenges,” he says. “We cannot trust it can do it without participation from other stakeholders.”


Growing Shortages of Water
Threaten China’s Development

Growing Shortages of Water Threaten China’s Development
With 20 percent of the world’s population but just 7 percent of its available freshwater, China faces serious water shortages as its economy booms and urbanization increases, Christina Larson reports. The government is planning massive water diversion projects, but environmentalists say conservation is the key.
Ultimately, the strategy for Ma’s group, Friends of Nature, and allied Chinese environmental organizations is built on a few key insights. First, information is power. To even begin to hold companies or governments accountable, you first have to be armed with good data. Second, the long-term battle is not about kicking out a particular corrupt official or closing down a certain factory, but about building a system that’s more transparent and open. That’s not easy to do anywhere in the world, and especially not in China. But Ma’s team and other green groups are trying.

And it’s not only environmentalists who stand to benefit from more access to data, but as World Resources Institute’s Deborah Seligsohn points out, “There’s a whole community of domestic scholars in China outside of government that could develop new tools and analysis. Without good public data, it’s hard to do peer review. Agencies like the China CDC need data to be able to do environmental health analysis. There are a lot of parties that will use new records as the government makes them available.”

There’s a long way to go. But access to pollution records is one area where China has become more open, not less, in recent years.

POSTED ON 20 Dec 2010 IN Energy Oceans Policy & Politics Policy & Politics Pollution & Health Water Asia Asia 


It will be interesting to see how this new approach affects global economic trends. In theory, it could be a win win for the U.S.: less outsourcing = more domestic jobs, plus the global benefits for the climate.

Luca Semprini

Posted by Luca Semprini on 21 Dec 2010

What a wonderful way to turn the watchful eye of first world corporate sustainability audits and carbon counters away from those who are forced to consume pollution from the manufacturing that the first world depends on and back on the supply chain powers who truly control it... China should encourage full, publicly accessible online mapping of environmental harms related to manufacturing, so that the first world corporations who truly hold the purse-strings are made accountable and environmental costs more fairly shared.

Posted by Kristine Bernauer on 31 Jan 2011

It is encouraging to see greater open access to records but a critical area is the lack of real time air quality information. The extent of the air quality problem based on real time monitors is virtually unknown. On top of that true air emission data from the host of sources is lacking so what ambient data is available cannot be associated with the source profiles so little can be done to begin making decisions about what are the most improtant sources to reduce.

Posted by Steven Arnold on 01 Feb 2011

Comments have been closed on this feature.
christina larsonABOUT THE AUTHOR
Christina Larson is a journalist focusing on international environmental issues, based in Beijing and Washington, D.C. Her assignments have taken her throughout China and Southeast Asia, and her writing has appeared in The New York Times, The International Herald Tribune, The New Republic, The Washington Monthly, and Foreign Policy, where she is a contributing editor. She is a fellow at the New America Foundation. In previous articles for Yale Environment 360, she has written from China about failed plans to build “eco-cities” and how China may soon be both the greenest and most polluted place on Earth.



Not on This Land: A Western Tribe
Takes a Stand and Says No to Big Coal

The Northern Cheyenne are opposing a proposed railroad that would cut through their ancestral lands to haul Montana coal to the Pacific coast for export. An e360 video reports on the Cheyenne’s fight against the railroad and the extraordinary coalition of tribal people and ranchers who have joined together to stop the project.

The Haunting Legacy of
South Africa’s Gold Mines

Thousands of abandoned gold mines are scattered across South Africa, polluting the water with toxics and filling the air with noxious dust. For the millions of people who live around these derelict sites, the health impacts can be severe.

Will Indonesian Fires Spark
Reform of Rogue Forest Sector?

Massive fires in Indonesia caused by the burning of forests and peatlands for agriculture have shrouded large areas of Southeast Asia in smoke this fall. But analysts say international anger over the fires could finally lead to a reduction in Indonesia’s runaway deforestation.

As the Fracking Boom Spreads,
One Watershed Draws the Line

After spreading across Pennsylvania, fracking for natural gas has run into government bans in the Delaware River watershed. The basins of the Delaware and nearby Susquehanna River offer a sharp contrast between what happens in places that allow fracking and those that do not.

Rallying Hip Hop Culture For
A More Inclusive Climate Fight

In an interview with Yale Environment 360, the Rev. Lennox Yearwood — a social and environmental activist and the head of the Hip Hop Caucus — explains why it’s vital that the climate and environmental movements become far more diverse.


MORE IN Reports

For Storing Electricity, Utilities
Are Turning to Pumped Hydro

by john roach
High-tech batteries may be garnering the headlines. But utilities from Spain to China are increasingly relying on pumped storage hydroelectricity – first used in the 1890s – to overcome the intermittent nature of wind and solar power.

On Thin Ice: Big Northern Lakes
Are Being Rapidly Transformed

by cheryl katz
As temperatures rise, the world’s iconic northern lakes are undergoing major changes that include swiftly warming waters, diminished ice cover, and outbreaks of harmful algae. Now, a global consortium of scientists is trying to assess the toll.

The Haunting Legacy of
South Africa’s Gold Mines

by mark olalde
Thousands of abandoned gold mines are scattered across South Africa, polluting the water with toxics and filling the air with noxious dust. For the millions of people who live around these derelict sites, the health impacts can be severe.

The Sushi Project: Farming Fish
And Rice in California's Fields

by jacques leslie
Innovative projects in California are using flooded rice fields to rear threatened species of Pacific salmon, mimicking the rich floodplains where juvenile salmon once thrived. This technique also shows promise for growing forage fish, which are increasingly threatened in the wild.

A Delicate Balance: Protecting
Northwest’s Glass Sponge Reefs

by nicola jones
Rare and extensive reefs of glass sponges are found only one place on earth – a stretch of the Pacific Northwest coast. Now, efforts are underway to identify and protect these fragile formations before they are obliterated by fishing vessels that trawl the bottom.

As the Fracking Boom Spreads,
One Watershed Draws the Line

by bruce stutz
After spreading across Pennsylvania, fracking for natural gas has run into government bans in the Delaware River watershed. The basins of the Delaware and nearby Susquehanna River offer a sharp contrast between what happens in places that allow fracking and those that do not.

Will Tidal and Wave Energy
Ever Live Up to Their Potential?

by sophia v. schweitzer
As solar and wind power grow, another renewable energy source with vast potential — the power of tides and waves — continues to lag far behind. But progress is now being made as governments and the private sector step up efforts to bring marine energy into the mainstream.

The Rapid and Startling Decline
Of World’s Vast Boreal Forests

by jim robbins
Scientists are becoming increasingly concerned about the fate of the huge boreal forest that spans from Scandinavia to northern Canada. Unprecedented warming in the region is jeopardizing the future of a critical ecosystem that makes up nearly a third of the earth’s forest cover.

Northern Forests Emerge
As the New Global Tinderbox

by ed struzik
Rapidly rising temperatures, changes in precipitation, and increased lightning strikes are leading to ever-larger wildfires in the northern forests of Alaska, Canada, and Siberia, with potentially severe ecological consequences.

For U.S. Tribes, a Movement to
Revive Native Foods and Lands

by cheryl katz
On ancestral lands, the Fond du Lac band in Minnesota is planting wild rice and restoring wetlands damaged by dams, industry, and logging. Their efforts are part of a growing trend by Native Americans to bring back traditional food sources and heal scarred landscapes.

e360 digest
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies


Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter



About e360
Submission Guidelines

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


e360 Digest
Video Reports


Business & Innovation
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology


Antarctica and the Arctic
Central & South America
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

The 2015 Yale e360 Video Contest winner documents a Northeastern town's bitter battle over a wind farm.
Watch the video.


The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 VIDEO

A 2015 Yale e360 Video Contest winner captures stunning images of wild salmon runs in Alaska.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.


A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

header image
Top Image: aerial view of Iceland. © Google & TerraMetrics.