30 Jun 2011: Report

Green Activists Feel Sting of
Chinese Government Crackdown

Even before this spring’s ominous clampdown on China’s public-interest lawyers, writers, and activists, the country’s fledgling environmental community felt the authorities’ noose tightening.

by christina larson

Seven years ago, China’s grassroots environmental activists won arguably their most remarkable victory. After a nationally coordinated, media-savvy anti-dam campaign, Premier Wen Jiabao responded in April 2004 by personally stepping in to suspend plans to dam China’s last free-flowing river, the Nujiang. With a nod to concerns that Chinese environmentalists had raised about the dam’s impact on local ecosystems, Wen asked that the plans be “seriously reviewed and decided scientifically.”

Wen’s response was in stark contrast to the government’s approach in 1989 when anti-dam activist Dai Qing had been sent to a maximum-security prison for a year for opposing the Three Gorges dam. To many in China’s fledgling environmental community, Wen’s action felt like the dawn of a new era — one in which China’s public would have a greater voice in shaping development.

Today, that moment looks less a beginning and more like a high-water mark — at least for that kind of direct-action campaign in China. With the country’s energy demand rising steeply (up 12 percent from last year), the government’s plan to build a cascade of hydropower stations on the Nujiang is now back in motion.

Two alarmed Chinese environmental groups — the Beijing-based NGO Green Earth Volunteers and Kunming-based Green Watershed — have in recent months conducted research trips along the Nujiang, documenting
Many of the trends that have choked grassroots green activism in China have been evident for years.
potential impacts. Armed with that research, a coalition of green groups sent a letter of concern to Premier Wen and China’s State Council before the most recent annual meeting of the National People’s Congress in March. But this time, their plea drew no response. Instead, the government has announced plans to build a flurry of new dams over the next decade — which will have a capacity equivalent to nearly twice that of all dams ever built in the United States. The foundation for at least one of the Nujiang dams is already under construction.

One does not often now hear in China the phrase gongzhong canyu — “public participation” — which less than five years ago was a popular mantra among Chinese environmentalists and sympathetic government officials. The notion the phrase captured was that protecting the environment over the long haul would require engaging China’s citizenry through the release of environmental impact assessments and other tools to gather public input. The chief advocate for gongzhong canyu at China’s environmental ministry, deputy director Pan Yue wrote in 2006 that “in China, the major problem is that environmental protection laws are not strictly observed and implemented due to a lack of democratic legal mechanisms for public participation.” But Pan has since been politically sidelined, and no likeminded official has stepped in to fill his shoes.

Many of the trends that have choked grassroots green activism in China have been evident for several years, well before this spring’s crackdown on activists and public intellectuals of various stripes — what Evan Osnos of the New Yorker has dubbed “the big chill.” Yet the current political climate has made matters worse.

When online talk of a “jasmine revolution” (a call for reform in the spirit of the uprisings this spring in North Africa) began to circulate in February on Chinese web sites, the government reacted swiftly and harshly. Dozens of
A new sense of dread has rippled through China’s broader public-interest community.
prominent Chinese activists, writers, and public-interest lawyers — most of whom had no explicit role in calling for a “jasmine revolution” — were detained or, even more threateningly, “disappeared.” (One of the most famous examples, the artist Ai Weiwei, has just been released.) Meanwhile at least 200 Chinese activists and lawyers were put under house arrest. While none of those targeted were devoted wholly to environmental causes, a new sense of dread has rippled through China’s broader public-interest community. The mood is tense.

Two Beijing-based lawyers who regularly take up environmental cases told me they were especially concerned about their prospects for having their licenses renewed this year, more so than in the past. (While the applications are pending, they did not want their names printed.)

Renee Xia, international director of the NGO Chinese Human Rights Defenders, explains how in China intimidation can spread like a contagion: “Lawyers who are largely doing work in what we call ‘public interest’ (including environmental issues) are all affected by the crackdown,” she says. “The fear factor is at play. The disappearance, detention, and then silencing of human rights lawyers sent out the warning to a much larger circle of lawyers. Many lawyers also believe, to be able to continue their work — to avoid being barred from practicing law at all – they would have to stay quiet for the time being.”

Wen Bo, a longtime Beijing-based activist who is in touch with many smaller environmental groups across the country, says he does not think green groups are being targeted per se — any more than other civil-society
Activist Wen Bo says the government does not want any single green group to gain too much influence.
groups in China. Yet he adds that he sees a clear glass ceiling for Chinese environmentalists; the government does not want any single group or activist to gain too much influence. “There are many small heroes, but it is hard to become a big hero, to impact a lot of people,” he says. “If you become too big, the government will be worried and will try to stop you. That is why there are many small groups, but few big trees in China’s environmental movement.”

In China, the sense of intimidation now rattling activists stems from various agencies and levels of government; it would be a mistake to assume that all events are necessarily part of a single coordinated campaign. That said, in the past two years, a handful of startling events have sent a chill through the green community. As Li Xiaorang, currently at a research scholar at the Institute for Philosophy and Public Policy at the University of Maryland, told a recent meeting of a U.S. congressional committee in Washington: “One distinction of this crackdown is that the government targets people beyond circles of political dissidents.”

One example of that was last year’s sentencing of Tibetan environmentalist Karma Samdrup to 15 years in prison, an unusually long sentence, for allegedly selling looted relics. His lawyer, Pu Zhiqiang, and the London-based NGO Free Tibet maintain the charges against him were concocted. Another is last June’s attack, apparently an attempted murder, on one of Beijing’s most dogged science reporters, Fang Xuanchang. The young journalist for Caijing magazine was brutally beaten on his way home from work. He had earned a reputation for writing hard-hitting articles about failed government-funded projects.


China’s Emerging
Environmental Movement

China’s Emerging Environmental Movement
In a 2008 series for Yale e360 on China’s emerging environmental movement, Christina Larson profiled Zhao Zhong, who was leading the fight to save the Yellow River, and reported on a legal aid center helping pollution victims stand up for their rights.
And finally, a concern that may seem comparatively mundane — yet is anything but. In 2010, the government announced that Chinese NGOs would need to have their grants from foreign foundations notarized by local authorities, an extra level of oversight. For groups that often exist on a shoestring budget, the threat of delayed or cancelled funding is paralyzing. As Xia explains, “The [fund-raising] situation has got worse — as part of the overall crackdown on independent NGOs.”

Perhaps the most tragic irony is that the vast majority of green groups in China see their mission not as flouting the government, but rather holding it accountable to its own goals — in short, helping Beijing to clean up the country’s air, soil, and rivers, as the government claims it wants to do. Alas, in anxious times, a would-be helping hand may be mistaken for one about to strike. That’s unfortunate for all in China, and all downstream.

POSTED ON 30 Jun 2011 IN Climate Energy Sustainability North America 


Thanks for this sobering report. Makes one wonder how to support such activists without endangering the cause.

Posted by Erik Hoffner on 04 Jul 2011

First I have to say that this is a good piece and the overall message that the author tried to deliver was clear, which I do agree.

What I think inappropriate is one example the author mentioned about the journalist Fang Xuanchang. - "Another is last June’s attack, apparently an attempted murder, on one of Beijing’s most dogged science reporters, Fang Xuanchang. The young journalist for Caijing magazine was brutally beaten on his way home from work. He had earned a reputation for writing hard-hitting articles about failed government-funded projects."

People can easily find more details about the attack/murder on Fang was related to his report on the scandal of a medical professor in mid-China. Although Fang was also famous for commenting government issues, the author loses her credibility (if not completely) when she links the attack/murder case (which she must know if she also bases in Beijing) together with Fang's other writings.

In fact, I think the piece is strong enough without the Fang's case, but after reading the whole thin, I'm why she included it. Is it just because a murder would make people think the Chinese government to be more evil?

Posted by Wei Liu on 12 Jul 2011

Comments have been closed on this feature.
christina larsonABOUT THE AUTHOR
Christina Larson is a journalist focusing on international environmental issues, based in Beijing and Washington, D.C. She is a contributing editor for Foreign Policy, and her writing has appeared in The New York Times, The International Herald Tribune, and The New Republic. In a 2008 series for Yale Environment 360 on China’s emerging environmental movement, she profiled Zhao Zhong, who was leading the fight to save the Yellow River, and reported on a Beijing-based legal aid center helping pollution victims stand up for their rights.



How China and U.S. Became
Unlikely Partners on Climate

Amid tensions between the U.S. and China, one issue has emerged on which the two nations are finding common ground: climate change. Their recent commitments on controlling emissions have created momentum that could help international climate talks in Paris in December.

The Soil Pollution Crisis in China:
A Cleanup Presents Daunting Challenge


In China’s Heartland, A Toxic Trail
Leads from Factories to Fields to Food


China’s Dirty Secret: The Boom Poisoned Its Soil and Crops
Three decades of rapid economic development in China has left a troubling legacy – widespread soil pollution that has contaminated food crops and jeopardized public health. Although they once labeled soil data a “state secret,” Chinese officials are slowly beginning to acknowledge this grave problem.
The first in a series.


Can Waterless Dyeing Processes
Clean Up the Clothing Industry?

One of the world’s most polluting industries is the textile-dyeing sector, which in China and other Asian nations releases trillions of liters of chemically tainted wastewater. But new waterless dyeing technologies, if adopted on a large scale, could sharply cut pollution from the clothing industry.


MORE IN Reports

For Storing Electricity, Utilities
Are Turning to Pumped Hydro

by john roach
High-tech batteries may be garnering the headlines. But utilities from Spain to China are increasingly relying on pumped storage hydroelectricity – first used in the 1890s – to overcome the intermittent nature of wind and solar power.

On Thin Ice: Big Northern Lakes
Are Being Rapidly Transformed

by cheryl katz
As temperatures rise, the world’s iconic northern lakes are undergoing major changes that include swiftly warming waters, diminished ice cover, and outbreaks of harmful algae. Now, a global consortium of scientists is trying to assess the toll.

The Haunting Legacy of
South Africa’s Gold Mines

by mark olalde
Thousands of abandoned gold mines are scattered across South Africa, polluting the water with toxics and filling the air with noxious dust. For the millions of people who live around these derelict sites, the health impacts can be severe.

The Sushi Project: Farming Fish
And Rice in California's Fields

by jacques leslie
Innovative projects in California are using flooded rice fields to rear threatened species of Pacific salmon, mimicking the rich floodplains where juvenile salmon once thrived. This technique also shows promise for growing forage fish, which are increasingly threatened in the wild.

A Delicate Balance: Protecting
Northwest’s Glass Sponge Reefs

by nicola jones
Rare and extensive reefs of glass sponges are found only one place on earth – a stretch of the Pacific Northwest coast. Now, efforts are underway to identify and protect these fragile formations before they are obliterated by fishing vessels that trawl the bottom.

As the Fracking Boom Spreads,
One Watershed Draws the Line

by bruce stutz
After spreading across Pennsylvania, fracking for natural gas has run into government bans in the Delaware River watershed. The basins of the Delaware and nearby Susquehanna River offer a sharp contrast between what happens in places that allow fracking and those that do not.

Will Tidal and Wave Energy
Ever Live Up to Their Potential?

by sophia v. schweitzer
As solar and wind power grow, another renewable energy source with vast potential — the power of tides and waves — continues to lag far behind. But progress is now being made as governments and the private sector step up efforts to bring marine energy into the mainstream.

The Rapid and Startling Decline
Of World’s Vast Boreal Forests

by jim robbins
Scientists are becoming increasingly concerned about the fate of the huge boreal forest that spans from Scandinavia to northern Canada. Unprecedented warming in the region is jeopardizing the future of a critical ecosystem that makes up nearly a third of the earth’s forest cover.

Northern Forests Emerge
As the New Global Tinderbox

by ed struzik
Rapidly rising temperatures, changes in precipitation, and increased lightning strikes are leading to ever-larger wildfires in the northern forests of Alaska, Canada, and Siberia, with potentially severe ecological consequences.

For U.S. Tribes, a Movement to
Revive Native Foods and Lands

by cheryl katz
On ancestral lands, the Fond du Lac band in Minnesota is planting wild rice and restoring wetlands damaged by dams, industry, and logging. Their efforts are part of a growing trend by Native Americans to bring back traditional food sources and heal scarred landscapes.

e360 digest
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies


Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter



About e360
Submission Guidelines

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


e360 Digest
Video Reports


Business & Innovation
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology


Antarctica and the Arctic
Central & South America
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

The 2015 Yale e360 Video Contest winner documents a Northeastern town's bitter battle over a wind farm.
Watch the video.


The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 VIDEO

A 2015 Yale e360 Video Contest winner captures stunning images of wild salmon runs in Alaska.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.


A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

header image
Top Image: aerial view of Iceland. © Google & TerraMetrics.