04 Nov 2014: Interview

Fostering Community Strategies For Saving the World's Oceans

To conservationist Ayana Elizabeth Johnson, getting coastal communities involved in plans to protect their waters is critical for protecting the planet's oceans. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, she talks about her work in one Caribbean island and how it shows how such a strategy can get results.

by crystal gammon

When the U.S. government announced in August that it planned to provide special protections for 20 varieties of coral under the Endangered Species Act, marine biologist Ayana Elizabeth Johnson suggested the move was not nearly enough. To her mind, the government’s justification for the protections — which hinged on the impacts of climate change and ocean acidification — overlooked much more immediate threats to these
“Ayana
Ayana Elizabeth Johnson
ecologically and economically vital corals: overfishing, pollution, and coastal development.

Aggressively curbing these, Johnson said, is something that can be done by coastal communities immediately — and with dramatic results.

As the executive director of the Waitt Institute, an ocean conservation organization based in La Jolla, California, Johnson recently put that approach to the test on the Caribbean island of Barbuda, near Antigua. Working with the government and local residents, the Waitt Institute’s Blue Halo Initiative helped to establish a comprehensive zoning system in Barbuda’s waters that was designed to halt overfishing and establish marine sanctuaries. In an interview with Yale Environment 360 web editor Crystal Gammon, Johnson discussed how she helped Barbuda to craft these rules, which were signed into law in August, and why she favors community-driven conservation efforts over more top-down approaches.

“We now have the data to prove that if you manage your resources really well locally, you have a much better chance of surviving the things you can’t control,” she said, “whether that’s climate change or storms or whatever it might be.”

Yale Environment 360: Why is it a bad idea to focus on reef and ocean conservation through the lens of climate change?

Ayana Elizabeth Johnson: It’s only part of the picture. The challenge is that we have overfishing, pollution, and coastal development operating alongside climate change, which has impacts that are often hard for people to get their heads around. Small islands in the Caribbean, for example, can’t stop climate change. But there are a lot of things they can do to build
Reefs that are managed well are not just a little bit healthier, they’re many times healthier.”
resilience in their ecosystems until international bodies and large governments rein in their carbon emissions. So the point is not to give up because there’s something big and out of your control, but to do what you can locally to make a difference. We now have the data to prove that if you manage your resources really well locally, you have a much better chance of surviving the things you can’t control, whether that’s climate change or storms or whatever it might be. And reefs that are managed well are not just a little bit healthier, they’re many times healthier.

e360: So are you in favor of an all-of-the-above approach to ocean conservation — management plus climate change mitigation?

Johnson: Right. It’s not either protect parrotfish or work to prevent climate change. That would be a totally false dichotomy. We’re just saying, “Why not focus on what we can do?” We’re not saying, “Don’t worry about the rest.”

e360: What are some examples of places that have had success with a local approach to fisheries management?

Johnson: Bermuda was the first place to prevent the use of fish traps, which in turn ended up protecting parrotfish, which in turn meant that there was less algae on the reefs and that the reefs have been able to kind of hold steady despite everything else that’s going on. Another example is Bonaire, whose economy is dependent on scuba diving tourism. They have put a number of measures in place to set up some protected areas and prevent really destructive fishing. Barbuda, of course, is the one closest to my heart. We’ve partnered with their government to do some really comprehensive thinking about what they want their ocean to look like in the future and how we can help them get there.

e360: How did the partnership with Barbuda arise?

Johnson: I started meeting with people in several Caribbean nations — fishermen, prime ministers, natural resource managers, hoteliers — so I could understand their priorities, their concerns, and whether they actually
All the boundaries on Barbuda's final zoning map were drawn by members of the community.”
wanted to see things change. Barbuda just felt like the right fit. It’s small — 15 or 16 hundred people — and the people know how dependent they are on healthy oceans for their fisheries, which are a large portion of their economy and a huge draw for tourism. They wanted to figure out a way to manage their fisheries better, but they didn’t have access to a lot of the technical components for doing that — teams of marine biologists to assess their reefs, experts to help make maps, or assistance with the legal drafting.

It was very interesting that everyone I spoke to in Barbuda wanted to see a change. No one was happy with the way things were. I don’t have time to spend a year convincing fishermen that their catches are getting worse and their reefs aren’t healthy. So we look for partners that come in with the mentality of “we want to fix it, we have the will, and you guys have the tools, and let’s team up.”

e360: What’s been the outcome, so far, of your work with Barbuda?

Johnson: It’s been two years since I first set foot on the island. After about a year and a half of public consultation, Barbuda put zoning and other types of legal policies in place. All the boundaries on the final zoning map were drawn by members of the community. None of them were drawn by scientists or anybody else — not even the politicians.

The Barbuda government has jurisdiction up to 3.5 miles from shore, and now one-third of their coastal areas have been designated as sanctuary zones where no fishing will occur. The zoning map also establishes
Waitt Institute Barbuda
The Waitt Institute
Johnson and the Waitt Institute team discuss ocean zoning strategies with Barbuda residents.
anchoring areas, as well as areas where no nets are to be used. The no-net zones are a great symbol to me, because it’s the fishermen who asked for that. They said, “We’re concerned about the sustainability of that practice and we’d like to see it end.” So now there’s a regulation that says nets cannot be used within 20 meters of a coral reef. It’s not a matter of convincing fishermen of basic ecological principles — they obviously know that habitat quality is important to fisheries’ health. It’s just a matter of figuring out how to provide the tools to legally codify their existing knowledge and preferences.

e360: How do Barbuda’s new conservation laws mesh with community traditions?

Johnson: One example is the Codrington lagoon. It’s been fished very heavily, and there’s a pier right in town where kids would drop a line after school and go fishing. The draft regulations at one point had closed the lagoon to all fishing for two years. But I was sitting on the dock one day watching these eight-year-olds fish, not catching much, and I thought, “Well, how terrible would it be if these kids couldn’t drop a line off the pier after school? They’re not the ones causing the fisheries to collapse, right?” So when the regulation became final, it contained an exception that says no fishing in the lagoon for two years, except with a hook and line from shore.

The other example is sharks. We had proposed a ban on catching sharks, and the community reaction was, “but we don’t even catch that many sharks.” What they really meant is, this is a part of our tradition, and our use is not a big problem, but we want to make sure that outsiders
What the public supports is often much more progressive than what politicians feel comfortable doing.”
aren’t also catching sharks. So the final outcome was to ban the export of sharks, and say sharks could only be caught for local consumption. That preserves an aspect of their culture.

I think trying to be flexible and creative is what ended up making the laws actually get passed. I recently compared the Waitt Institute’s original policy recommendations with the final regulations. They’re hugely different. They tackle the same issues but they’ve evolved dramatically, and that’s a great thing because it shows that community feedback really was incorporated.

e360: On what time scale do you think Barbuda will start seeing success, either in the fisheries or the community as a whole?

Johnson: It depends on how you’re measuring success. For people who measure success in the number of fish or the amount of coral, that’s going to take time, because coral grows about one centimeter a year, and fish take years to reproduce. Lobsters, which are Barbuda’s primary export, don’t reproduce until they’re about three years old. There’s definitely going to be a lag, but I think we’re going to start seeing some ecological benefits within about three years. But if we’re able to cut the amount of illegal fishing in Barbuda’s waters, then fishermen will start to see benefits even sooner. That will depend on enforcement, of course, not just having the laws on paper.

If you’re measuring success in dollars, in economic factors such as ecotourism, that kind of stuff might take a little longer.

ALSO FROM YALE e360

People or Parks: The Human
Factor in Protecting Wildlife

People or Parks
Recent studies in Asia and Australia found that community-managed areas can sometimes do better than traditional parks at preserving habitat and biodiversity. When it comes to conservation, maybe local people are not the problem, but the solution.
READ MORE
So whether it’s dollars or fish, I think it’ll take a few years.

e360: Based on your work in Barbuda, do you see any implications for more developed and regulated areas such as Florida or Australia?

Johnson: At the most general level, yes, the Waitt Institute’s “you have the will, we have the tools” approach could work anywhere. We think that zoning and protected areas should be part of it, fisheries management should be part of it, but exactly what form it takes completely depends on the priorities of the location. What’s really preventing Florida and Australia from protecting their coral reefs or rebuilding fisheries that have effectively collapsed is not necessarily money or technical expertise — there are plenty of very smart and capable scientists in both places. In many cases it comes down to political will. What the public supports is often much more progressive than what politicians feel comfortable doing.



POSTED ON 04 Nov 2014 IN Biodiversity Biodiversity Forests Oceans Policy & Politics Science & Technology Sustainability Central & South America North America 

COMMENTS


It can be overwhelming to think about the big, complex, "wicked" problems that face the environment & the people who depend on it. Thank you Ayana & Yale E360 for the reminder to take a step back, talk to people, and focus on what can be accomplished.
Posted by Lisa Feldkamp on 04 Nov 2014


POST A COMMENT

Comments are moderated and will be reviewed before they are posted to ensure they are on topic, relevant, and not abusive. They may be edited for length and clarity. By filling out this form, you give Yale Environment 360 permission to publish this comment.

Name 
Email address 
Comment 
 
Please type the text shown in the graphic.



 
 

RELATED ARTICLES


Chocolate in the Jungle: The Battle
To Save a Disappearing Rainforest


READ MORE

Views: Los Angeles Aims to
Revitalize a Concrete River


READ MORE

How to Restore an Urban River?
Los Angeles Looks to Find Out

Officials are moving ahead with a major revitalization of the Los Angeles River – removing miles of concrete along its banks and re-greening areas now covered with pavement. But the project raises an intriguing question: Just how much of an urban river can be returned to nature?
READ MORE

How Growing Sea Plants Can
Help Slow Ocean Acidification

Researchers are finding that kelp, eelgrass, and other vegetation can effectively absorb CO2 and reduce acidity in the ocean. Growing these plants in local waters, scientists say, could help mitigate the damaging impacts of acidification on marine life.
READ MORE

Vanishing Act: What’s Causing Sharp
Decline in Insects and Why It Matters

Insect populations are declining dramatically in many parts of the world, recent studies show. Researchers say various factors, from monoculture farming to habitat loss, are to blame for the plight of insects, which are essential to agriculture and ecosystems.
READ MORE

 

MORE IN Interviews


At Ground Zero for Rising Seas,
TV Weatherman Talks Climate

by diane toomey
John Morales is part of a new breed of television weather forecasters seeking to educate viewers on climate change and the threat it poses. In South Florida, where sea level rise is already causing periodic flooding, he has a receptive audience.
READ MORE

Unable to Endure Rising Seas,
Alaskan Villages Stuck in Limbo

by diane toomey
As an advocate for Alaska’s Native communities, Robin Bronen points to a bureaucratic Catch-22 — villages cannot get government support to relocate in the face of climate-induced threats, but they are no longer receiving funds to repair their crumbling infrastructure.
READ MORE

Why CO2 'Air Capture' Could Be
Key to Slowing Global Warming

by richard schiffman
Physicist Klaus Lackner has long advocated deploying devices that extract carbon dioxide from the atmosphere to combat climate change. Now, as emissions keep soaring, Lackner says in a Yale Environment 360 interview that such “air capture” approaches may be our last best hope.
READ MORE

Bringing Energy Upgrades
To the Nation’s Inner Cities

by diane toomey
Donnel Baird has launched a startup that aims to revolutionize how small businesses and nonprofits secure funding for energy efficiency and clean energy projects in low-income neighborhoods. In a Yale Environment 360 interview, he talks about how he plans to bring his vision to dozens of U.S. cities.
READ MORE

From Mass Coral Bleaching,
A Scientist Looks for Lessons

by katherine bagley
For climate scientist Kim Cobb, this year’s massive bleaching of coral reefs is providing sobering insights into the impacts of global warming. Yale Environment 360 talked with Cobb about the bleaching events and the push to make reefs more resilient to rising temperatures.
READ MORE

For James Hansen, the Science
Demands Activism on Climate

by katherine bagley
Climate scientist James Hansen has crossed the classic divide between research and activism. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he responds to critics and explains why he believes the reality of climate change requires him to speak out.
READ MORE

How Ocean Noise Pollution
Wreaks Havoc on Marine Life

by richard schiffman
Marine scientist Christopher Clark has spent his career listening in on what he calls “the song of life” in the world’s oceans. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he explains how these marine habitats are under assault from extreme—but preventable—noise pollution.
READ MORE

How to Talk About Clean
Energy With Conservatives

by diane toomey
Angel Garcia, of Young Conservatives for Energy Reform, is working to persuade Republicans about the need for renewable energy. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he explains why his group avoids mentioning climate change when it makes its pitch to conservatives
READ MORE

In Flint Crisis, A New Model
For Environmental Journalism

by cynthia barnett
Curt Guyette is an investigative reporter who dug deeper into the Flint water crisis. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, he explains his work as a journalist employed by a Michigan nonprofit and how it could be a model for in-depth, local reporting on the environment.
READ MORE

Rethinking Urban Landscapes
To Adapt to Rising Sea Levels

by winifred bird
Landscape architect Kristina Hill focuses on helping cities adapt to climate change, particularly sea level rise. In an interview with Yale Environment 360, she discusses the challenges, solutions, and costs of saving cities from encroaching oceans.
READ MORE


e360 digest
Yale
Yale Environment 360 is
a publication of the
Yale School of Forestry
& Environmental Studies
.

SEARCH e360



Donate to Yale Environment 360
Yale Environment 360 Newsletter


CONNECT


ABOUT

About e360
Contact
Submission Guidelines
Reprints

E360 en Español

Universia partnership
Yale Environment 360 articles are now available in Spanish and Portuguese on Universia, the online educational network.
Visit the site.


DEPARTMENTS

Opinion
Reports
Analysis
Interviews
Forums
e360 Digest
Podcasts
Video Reports

TOPICS

Biodiversity
Business & Innovation
Climate
Energy
Forests
Oceans
Policy & Politics
Pollution & Health
Science & Technology
Sustainability
Urbanization
Water

REGIONS

Antarctica and the Arctic
Africa
Asia
Australia
Central & South America
Europe
Middle East
North America

e360 VIDEO

“video
Tribal people and ranchers join together to stop a project that would haul coal across their Montana land.
Watch the video.

e360 MOBILE

Mobile
The latest
from Yale
Environment 360
is now available for mobile devices at e360.yale.edu/mobile.

e360 PHOTO ESSAY

“Alaska
An aerial view of why Europe’s per capita carbon emissions are less than 50 percent of those in the U.S.
View the photos.

e360 VIDEO

“Ugandan
Ugandan scientists monitor the impact of climate change on one of Africa’s most diverse forests and its extraordinary wildlife.
Learn more.

e360 VIDEO

Food waste
An e360 video series looks at the staggering amount of food wasted in the U.S. – a problem with major human and environmental costs.
Watch the video.

e360 VIDEO

Colorado wildfires
An e360 video goes onto the front lines with Colorado firefighters confronting deadly blazes fueled by a hotter, drier climate.
Watch the video.

e360 SPECIAL REPORT

“Tainted
A three-part series Tainted Harvest looks at the soil pollution crisis in China, the threat it poses to the food supply, and the complexity of any cleanup.
Read the series.

OF INTEREST



Yale