A top Indian official bluntly told U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton that there is “simply no case” for the U.S. and the West to push India to agree to a cap on carbon dioxide emissions, especially considering that India has among the lowest per capita emissions worldwide. Visiting an energy-efficient office building with Clinton, India’s environment and forests minister, Jairam Ramesh, added that, “If this pressure is not enough, we also face the threat of carbon tariffs on our exports to countries such as yours.” He was referring to an energy and climate bill, recently approved by the U.S. House of Representatives, that would impose import tariffs on goods from countries that do not put a price on carbon emissions. Clinton assured Ramesh that the U.S. “will not do anything that would limit India’s economic progress.” But she argued that, given India’s rapidly growing population and rising standards of living, per capita emissions are not a fair measure of climate impact. To some degree, the public debate is posturing before climate talks later this year in Copenhagen; Ramesh said that while India will not agree to emissions reduction targets, “it is possible for us to narrow our positions.”
Visit by Hillary Clinton Highlights India-U.S. Split on Climate
More From E360
-
INTERVIEW
How One South African Community Stopped Shell Oil in Its Tracks
-
ANALYSIS
Will New Leader End Progress in Saving Indonesia’s Forests?
-
Oceans
Dire Straits: Can a Fishing Ban Save the Elusive European Eel?
-
Climate
Scientists Are Trying to Coax the Ocean to Absorb More CO2
-
INTERVIEW
Marina Silva on Brazil’s Fight to Turn the Tide on Deforestation
-
Solutions
Solomon Islands Tribes Sell Carbon Credits, Not Their Trees
-
INTERVIEW
With Sea Turtles in Peril, a Call for New Strategies to Save Them
-
RIVERS
Jared Kushner Has Big Plans for Delta of Europe’s Last Wild River
-
Energy
A Nuclear Power Revival Is Sparking a Surge in Uranium Mining
-
OPINION
Despite Official Vote, the Evidence of the Anthropocene Is Clear
-
INTERVIEW
At 11,500 Feet, a ‘Climate Fast’ to Save the Melting Himalaya
-
Oceans
Octopuses Are Highly Intelligent. Should They Be Farmed for Food?